Editorial Archives | ProspectiveDoctor The premier resource for future doctors. Thu, 30 Mar 2023 13:39:03 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.1 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/cropped-pdr-favicon-rounded-1-32x32.png Editorial Archives | ProspectiveDoctor 32 32 Challenges of Minorities Entering Medicine https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/challenges-of-minorities-entering-medicine/ Tue, 27 Oct 2015 03:02:16 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=4088

“What do you do when you’re the smartest person in your group?” Dr. Forrester Lee, the Director of Multicultural Affairs at the Yale School of Medicine smiled as he posed the thoughtful question. We were a handful of African and Latino American students sitting around a warmly-lit conference room table. The room was silent. I …

The post Challenges of Minorities Entering Medicine appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

“What do you do when you’re the smartest person in your group?” Dr. Forrester Lee, the Director of Multicultural Affairs at the Yale School of Medicine smiled as he posed the thoughtful question. We were a handful of African and Latino American students sitting around a warmly-lit conference room table. The room was silent. I sat inconspicuously among them, a wide-eyed, timid eighteen-year-old black kid. I don’t think I had a clue about the answer, really. I just had some vague sense that the question was more a riddle than a sincere attempt to figure out our individual altruistic tendencies. “Maybe it becomes one’s responsibility to help and guide those around you that are less fortunate”, one student beside me offered.

“You find a smarter group”, Dr. Lee finished.

Racial identity and socioeconomic status permeate many aspects of American society, and thus have real impact on all of us. In K-12 education, staggering research provides evidence that there is a performance gap between the rich and poor. Populations associated with low income areas tend to, historically, be predominantly (but by no means exclusively) African and Latino Americans. This is no secret. As a consequence, many of us who come from these communities can fall into two sequential traps. The first is performance at a mediocre level of achievement, receiving praise from those around us for simply going through the motions of success. Propagated by noble institutions such as affirmative action, it can be easy to lower our own expectations of achievement and settle for less. The second trap for those who do escape the first is to find themselves fighting a chip on their shoulder, seemingly attempting to prove themselves in what can be an unforgiving society. These are the two main challenges of minorities entering medicine.

||Read: Nursing to Medicine||

In his statement, quoted from Les Brown, Dr. Lee was addressing both categorical pitfalls. The first directly, and the second in a bit more indirect fashion.

We celebrate individuals like Jeremy Lin for the same reasons we celebrate a young child from the inner city who has dreams of becoming a doctor. Though they may not perform as a top star or student, it is the subtle purpose to defy expectations that inspires us. Yet in this emotional high we can sometimes do them a disservice. We can come to accept simply “blending in”, rather than true exceptional performance and leadership. Lower standards can be contagious. We’ve all lived them, gotten to know their signs and symptoms. One does not need to search very far to find examples in support of this. Traces of them existed when I persistently groaned about the rigor of my life science courses, or the nagging commentary uttered by my fellow students about clinical examination rubrics.

If the flame that fuels our individual drive for excellence can be dimmed by lukewarm mediocrity, might it be rekindled by fire of outstanding quality? I believe so. Research from the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology confirms this. The study authors showed that performance gaps on exams composed of Graduate Record Examination content between blacks and whites all but disappeared in the period before Obama’s nomination to the period after his acceptance speech. It is very clear. The extent of our abilities is based, at least in part, on our willingness to believe we have them in the first place. Surrounding ourselves and others with positive voices that not only say “yes we can”, but “yes we will” has the power to change us.

||Read: A Future Doctor’s Greatest Struggle||

So, you’ve floated on, travelled the narrow road and worked hard to become the high achieving bright young man or woman you are today. I have found that it is here that true self-examination must occur. The pursuit of excellence can, but not always, be fueled by blind passion. For those rare moments of reflection in the day, month, or year, we can find ourselves faced with what is known as an imposter syndrome. Questions like: “do I truly deserve to be here?” coupled with scarce examples of successful minority role models might lead us to over-compensate, proving to the world, and ultimately, our own selves that we have a right to stake our claim at XYZ School of Medicine. There is no easy way to combat this mindset.

However, I do think it is possible—given that we keep our eyes on the prize. When I was a nursing student, I had few examples of black male nurses to look up to. After school, when I’d arrived to begin working on my unit, I quickly realized I was the only African American male Registered Nurse on a unit employing close to 50 nurses. But when I walked into each patient room—into the room of each grandmother, son, or cousin, I saw that all of my reservations were quickly hushed. This was the only reality I could know professionally. These thoughts had nowhere else to go but out the window.

Of course, there is the small voice that returns to say that I still needed to perform. As with any relationship, a healthy sense of self- trust is foundational.

||Read: End Premed Culture||

When interviewed about his on-stage role in the Elephant Man, Bradley Cooper says it is his belief in his ability to become, rather than act as the elephant man, that lead to his transformation into the character. He says, “If I can’t make the leap of faith…to believe it, the audience won’t either”. In a proportional way, it is the same for us. If we do not believe we can take the leap and become truly immersed in the care of our patients, the fruit derived from executing our roles as providers might be lacking as well.

Grappling with these two potential pitfalls is human. However I think that true failure exists in leaning to the conclusion that to be a minority is to somehow be cursed. On the contrary, it is an enormous blessing. Neither the human spirit, nor competence is marked by race. This universal truth helps me to see that our commonalities can easily overpower our differences, and that we should treat each other the way we would hope to be treated.

I suspect this is why most prospective doctors are interested in entering medicine in the first place.

Diboro Kanabolo is a medical student at Pritzker School of Medicine, University of Chicago. He worked 2 years as a nurse prior to going to medical school.

The post Challenges of Minorities Entering Medicine appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Diversity in Medical Secondary Applications https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/diversity-in-medical-secondary-applications/ Wed, 26 Aug 2015 21:44:13 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/pdr2/2013/12/05/diversity-in-secondary-medical-applications/

Descend no further because this is the bottom line: if you are a premed applying to medical school, you will be required to take part in the timeless discussion of diversity and healthcare. It’s advantageous to acknowledge this as you find yourself diligently completing countless secondary application prompts discussing diversity and inclusion. Of the 27 …

The post Diversity in Medical Secondary Applications appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

Descend no further because this is the bottom line: if you are a premed applying to medical school, you will be required to take part in the timeless discussion of diversity and healthcare. It’s advantageous to acknowledge this as you find yourself diligently completing countless secondary application prompts discussing diversity and inclusion. Of the 27 secondary applications I submitted, 19 of them had questions that required me in some way to discuss how I contributed to the diversity of their school, or discuss why diversity is so important in medicine. The irony of asking this question is that secondary applications as a whole are not very diverse. Secondary applications in general have a lot of overlapping essay prompts that will draw upon the same common themes. That being said, one of the best preparations you can do for writing on hot topics such as diversity is to keep it in mind during your daily routine, and engage in discussions with your friends, family, adversaries, coworkers and teachers when possible.

||Learn about more common secondary application topics||

In the context of medical school admissions, the term “diversity” can sometimes be unconsciously replaced with the term “race” or “heritage.” The first thing to acknowledge is that when it comes to admissions, race does matters, which isn’t necessarily a good or bad or even causative association, but is simply another factor to consider throughout the application cycle. The AAMC ‘s data shows that for allopathic medical schools in 2011, the average GPA for Mexican-American and African-American matriculants was 3.53 and 3.44, with MCAT averages of 29 and 26.3 respectively. Yes, the scores are different, the premed qualifications are somewhat different, and I would say that this is in a spirited effort to produce a class of doctors that more accurately mirrors and connects to our patient populations. Achieving a more balanced physician pool is a an inspiring mission for the healthcare field, and the affirmative action itself remains an icon of medicine’s inclusivity.

||Learn more about ethnicity and medical school applications||

So how does this apply to you? Diversity applies to you because when you write your secondaries, you will have to explain how you contribute to the diversity of the class, and I don’t want you to fall prey to some of the same misconceptions that I did. The application process had me so conditioned that when I received the topics asking me to write about my diversity, my mind immediately landed on one thing- race. As I looked at that first prompt I thought “Ohhh great. I’m white, I’m middle class and my parents are not only still alive and married, but are both Jewish.” I felt extraordinarily grateful for what I had, but I also felt like the antithesis of diversity. I saw my ‘lack of diversity’ as a disadvantage. When being constantly fed concepts and opinions of diversity it is so easy to make it synonymous with race, ethnicity and culture. While all these factors contribute to diversity, the definition bends far beyond the scope of race. Do not get trapped within one-dimensional definitions of diversity. I have known a lot of premeds who have felt the need to outsource their diversity in their applications by talking about how they served with underprivileged youth of different races, or went on a global medical trip to Uganda where they developed a global view of medicine. I am not saying those experiences don’t have a place within your application, but they should not replace your own diversity. These questions of diversity give you a chance to personally connect with the admissions office at a school, and for many admissions committees it can be one of the dominating factors of your application.

In case you’re wondering what exactly I mean by approaching topics on diversity, consider the following examples from my very own class. I have two classmates who are gifted in math and computer science but whose path brought them into medicine instead. This is one aspect of the diversity they bring to our class, and they’ve used their skill to create a new elective at our school that teaches students analytic programs like R for their research, and they also teach how math can make scientific research stronger. Another student loved to run throughout college and rallies students in our class to go do half marathons and runs together, and yet another student acts as our classes social lightning rod by consistently organizing efforts for social events and keeping us all bonded and balanced. My diversity came in the form of extensive experience in emergency prehospital care, and I’m finding ways to try to share that with others. Everyone has something that they bring to the table, whether it is academic, emotional, athletic, or social.

Take the time to search through what makes you diverse. If your race, ethnicity and culture truly relate to your unique contributions to your medical school class then by all means convey that to the admissions committee, but know that these questions can be brought in many directions. You do not have an obligation to play into the advantages and disadvantages of race and culture in your statements, but you should feel an obligation to represent yourself honestly. Although I’m not racially unique when it comes to the field of medicine, I bring my unique accomplishments, experiences and opinions to the table. I know what those are, find yours and create your own definition of diversity for your statements.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of ProspectiveDoctor

The post Diversity in Medical Secondary Applications appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
The Healing Capacity of Empathic Curiosity in Medicine https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/healing-capacity-empathic-curiosity-medicine/ Tue, 10 Mar 2015 00:48:19 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3380

By Larry Laveman and Evan Laveman Medicine is a plurality of science and humanitarian principles measured by scientific research. Unfortunately, there is very little scientific research on the effects of our humanity on medical outcomes. Since the idea of empathy in medicine is vague and open to interpretation, the Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy was …

The post The Healing Capacity of Empathic Curiosity in Medicine appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

By Larry Laveman and Evan Laveman

Medicine is a plurality of science and humanitarian principles measured by scientific research. Unfortunately, there is very little scientific research on the effects of our humanity on medical outcomes. Since the idea of empathy in medicine is vague and open to interpretation, the Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy was established to create an objective rating scale of physician empathy. The scale, however, tries to reduce “empathy” to a research variable, which is like trying to measure self-esteem with a thermometer. One simply cannot be used to measure the other. Empathy is not empirical; it is personal, which is why there is widespread disagreement on its definition.

Regardless, there is general agreement among educators that empathy is important to patient care. Doctors, however, may be tempted to shy away from being empathic, thinking it may lead to emotional fatigue, take too much time, or complicate their approach to the patient’s healthcare needs. There is also a prevalent and preconceived notion that detachment can serve as an essential protective mechanism to help them remain objective, analytic, and useful. Studies have shown that student empathy erodes in medical school as the initial idealistic desire to “help” is replaced by a more hardened de-idealized need to survive the constant exposure to illness and suffering. Ironically, research also seems to indicate a correlation between emotionally inclusive care shown to patients and successful outcomes. As a result, medical schools across the nation are starting to develop curriculum and admissions criteria based on compassion, communication, and empathy.

Arguably, the most important part of creating a therapeutic relationship with a patient is the ability to be empathically engaged. Showing interest, which is more than just a demonstration of sympathy, has been found to be at the core of all therapeutic alliances and has recently been directly linked to positive patient outcomes in medicine.  The distinction between sympathy and empathy is important, since one carries more of an emotional relevance and the other a cognitive grasping of the emotional component. When you feel for a patient’s condition, you are sympathetic. When you have an understanding of a patient’s condition, not just by mere identification through your own experience, you are empathic.

To make the concept of empathy clearer, I use the term “empathic curiosity” to demonstrate the genuine sense of connecting with a patient through interest, understanding and compassion. Curiosity is conveyed by asking questions. When I am curious I’ll ask questions that elicit more information, but when I am merely sympathetic, I make statements such as, “I feel for what you’re going through.”  The difference between curiosity and sympathy is a key element to building strong, trusting relationships. Empathic Curiosity draws no conclusions, makes no statements, is free of assumptions, has no implied identification with the patient and most importantly, and does not attempt to interpret behavior. To have empathic curiosity is to ask open-ended questions that cause the patient to think differently about how they perceive their situation and to problem-solve in more effective ways. In other words, it engages the patient. It’s more than just “putting yourself in their shoes”, it’s the desire to know, combined with an interest in understanding, complimented by a direct action that is clearly articulated to the patient.

Empathic Curiosity allows patients to convey their story and to clarify relevant points so the patient feels “heard.”  It provides a space for interaction, and not just a question and answer assessment. It’s more than just ordering a battery of tests because you’re interested in confirming or rejecting your diagnosis. It’s a validation of the patient’s symptoms by taking a genuine interest in the patient through a compassionate, caring and genuine concern for their well-being. In the absence of curiosity, the healthcare provider fails to properly understand the patient. Starting with a question such as, “tell me about your history with tobacco” can open up a very productive and informative conversation, followed by “how do you view your association with tobacco”, rather than just asking the standard question, “Do you smoke?”

Jon Kabat-Zinn first used the term “participatory medicine” to describe the doctor/patient collaboration around treatment strategies. Subsequent studies have shown that by participating in their own care, patients have been able to reduce their symptomology. Zinn’s particular form of participatory medicine, Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction, reduces chronic stress reactions in the body that cause all sorts of symptoms from internal ailments to pain, indigestion, fatigue and chronic illness. Researchers have also shown that by changing the body’s response mechanism to stress through mindful movement, eating, meditation and awareness patients are able to become more resilient and better able to regulate their own bodies producing greater overall health.

When a patient visits a doctor or an emergency room the tone is set once the patient is greeted by the receptionist in the lobby. If the environment is cold and alienating the patient will exhibit a greater stress response. As fear and uncertainty set in the patient can become alienated from the healing process. Empathic Curiosity can set the tone for positive engagement. As research has begun to show, once the physician exhibits empathy and curiosity about their patient’s disposition a collaborative relationship is formed that enhances healing. This goes far beyond a physician’s ability to assess and treat on a medical level. Empathic Curiosity evokes a healing response from the patient that is not completely understood at this time. But one thing is clear; the more empathy being shown by a physician to a patient, the greater the likelihood of a positive outcome.

The post The Healing Capacity of Empathic Curiosity in Medicine appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
The Healing Power of Touch https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/healing-power-of-touch/ Thu, 26 Feb 2015 05:49:19 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3338

From the time we are babies, we long for the touch of our mother or father. As children grow, they usually put their arms up and want to be embraced or held. I even notice that my 5-month-old daughter is beginning to reach out to grab my face, my nose or my chin. Over the …

The post The Healing Power of Touch appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

From the time we are babies, we long for the touch of our mother or father. As children grow, they usually put their arms up and want to be embraced or held. I even notice that my 5-month-old daughter is beginning to reach out to grab my face, my nose or my chin. Over the past 5 months that my wife has been breastfeeding her, Lily (my daughter) has learned to grab onto my wife and it is a beautiful act to witness. Touch is one of the first senses that Lily is beginning to develop and explore, just like other infants her age.

During the preclinical years of medical school, we all begin to view touch in a different way. Through physical examination courses, we learn how to palpate an abdomen or spleen, auscultate the heart, and feel for lymph nodes. At first, laying hands on a classmate can be uncomfortable. It becomes even more nerve-wracking when you are on the wards during your 3rd and 4th years with actual patients. Both allopathic (MD) and osteopathic (DO) medical students have to learn the art of touch related to physical examination in order to graduate medical school.

I earned my Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine from Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine (LECOM) Bradenton, Florida in 2008. One fundamental difference between allopathic and osteopathic medical education is the osteopathic manual manipulation (OMM, or Osteopathic Manipulative Therapy, OMT). OMM is a hands-on approach to diagnose and treat not only musculoskeletal disorders but also a plethora of other conditions such as sinus congestion, acid reflux, and methods to improve lymphatic circulation. As stated in an Osteopathic medical text, “Foundation of Osteopathic Medicine”* , DO physicians embrace the following principles: “the person is a unit composed of body, mind, and spirit” and “the body is capable of homeostasis, self-healing, and health maintenance”.

||Read: Develop Compassion Before Medical School||

Through the OMT courses during the preclinical years, we became more familiar with our classmates in an almost intimate way. Whether it was the first time awkwardly palpating the piriformis muscle or sacrum of a female classmate or the gracilis muscle of a male classmate, we continued to become more at ease evaluating various regions of the body. We improved our sense of touch and developed the Meissner’s and Pacinian corpuscles in our fingertips.

Although I may not manually adjust spines in my exam room and frankly have allowed my OMT skills to slip, I continue to realize that the art of touch transcends the MD or DO after a physician’s name. As a physician, I have approximately 2000 patients in my practice. When I evaluate them, I try to stick to rules I have established for myself and want to share:

“The 3 rules of arms length”
1. Always be within an arm’s length of a patient to hold their hand if they need consolation
2. Always be within an arm’s length of a box of tissue incase a patient is crying
3. Always be within an arm’s length of the door incase a patient tries to attack you

Rule number 3 is more for the purpose of humor. However number 1 and 2 should be engrained in your memory.

In effortless ways, I practice the art of touch daily. It has become second nature for me. For example, while I auscultate the lungs of a patient, if I am standing perpendicular to the exam table, I move my stethoscope with one hand and steady myself with my other hand on their shoulder. Even if I know that a patient has only presented to discuss depression or anxiety, I listen to their grief and am attentive emotionally but then also physically examine their heart with my stethoscope. I make sure to place a hand on their shoulder while they cry as I present a box of tissues with the other. Touch is comforting and can help to make a patient feel that their physician is sympathetic or even empathetic.

||Read: Connect With the Patient Behind the Disease||

If a patient feels comfortable enough to divulge their emotions and feelings to a physician in a small, enclosed exam room, I believe it helps them to know that they are not alone. The art of touch is truly important in the practice of compassionate medicine. Avoiding physical contact with a patient to prevent transference is very poor medicine. The art of laying ones hands on a patient reaffirms the unique bond between a physician and patient – as we take an oath to protect their privacy and secrets with scrupulous honor.

It is crucial that a physician be attentive to a patient’s needs by watching their body language. It is amazing to see how a grieving widow or widower can be eased or an anxious patient have their apprehensions allayed when their physician holds their hand as they pour out their emotions during a cathartic office encounter. Even offering an open arm embrace can enhance the relationship with your patients. I have many patients that I hug because they are part of my medical home (I don’t call it my office).

Again, during my preclinical years as an Osteopathic medical student, we became familiar with our classmates through weekly workshops and again modesty was easily cast aside. As a result, it made a hands-on approach more natural and I slowly became more cognizant of my body language towards others in general. As many DOs will tell you – the DO handshake is a hug. If medical students can begin to practice making simple physical contact with others, even when shaking hands and grasping the interlocked hands with your left hand, you will be off to a great start.

||Read: Truth and Compassion in Medicine||

As Leo Buscaglia said, “Too often we underestimate the power of a touch, a smile, a kind word, a listening ear, an honest compliment, or the smallest act of caring, all of which have the potential to turn a life around.”

To reiterate – most patients can read body language. Remember that. Also, some textbooks I have come across refer to patients as “clients”. It is unfortunate and boorish that an academician would use that cold and indifferent term “client”. When I have heard any healthcare student use the term “client”, I promptly admonish them for not showing respect to those who entrust their healthcare to us.

Whether you will eventually earn your “MD” or “DO”, I encourage you to become more cognizant of your body language, to shake the hands of each and every patient and attempt to make some physical contact. Yes students, you must improve your clinical acumen by poring over your medical textbooks, but a physician will be truly successful if they continue to practice small acts of humanity to sharpen their people skills and the ability to place patients at ease. Don’t be afraid to offer a hug to a patient – it can help you to build a great patient base which becomes more like a family as time goes on. Do no underestimate the healing power of touch. You may touch your patients during a physical exam, but more importantly, you may touch their hearts. That is when you know that all of the time spent studying was truly worth it.

* Ward RC. Foundation of Osteopathic Medicine. 2nd ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins.; 2002.

Dr. Samuel Urick is an Internal Medicine physician who practices primary care at Robinson Township in Pennsylvania. He graduated from Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine in Bradenton, Florida. When he’s not working, he enjoys cooking (especially Italian food), baking, dancing, listening to Frank Sinatra, watching comedy, learning about American History, blogging, and getting to know other people. Learn more about his practice at https://www.drsamurick.com/.

The post The Healing Power of Touch appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
A Future Doctor’s Greatest Struggle https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/a-future-doctors-greatest-struggle/ Mon, 26 Jan 2015 21:47:08 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3259

As a freshman in college, I thought about all the requirements it would take to go to medical school and, honestly, I was completely overwhelmed. I couldn’t fathom how I could achieve a high GPA and MCAT while balancing a bunch of extracurricular activities. Nevertheless, as I reflect on what my greatest struggles are and …

The post A Future Doctor’s Greatest Struggle appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

As a freshman in college, I thought about all the requirements it would take to go to medical school and, honestly, I was completely overwhelmed. I couldn’t fathom how I could achieve a high GPA and MCAT while balancing a bunch of extracurricular activities. Nevertheless, as I reflect on what my greatest struggles are and have been, I’m realizing that even though I feared the MCAT, it wasn’t as great of a hurdle as I thought it was; it was actually enjoyable (to a certain extent). Even applying for medical schools, although it was a pretty stressful period in my life, was not my biggest struggle. Even USMLE Step 1, which is arguably the most important test of my life, doesn’t fit the criteria. So what is a future doctor’s greatest struggle?

A future doctor’s greatest struggle, I believe, is self-centeredness.

||Read: Develop Compassion Before Medical School||

Medicine, by nature, is a giving profession. Doctors train for many years so that they can have the skills in order to serve patients in the future. It requires sacrifice and dedication to a cause greater than ourselves. Nevertheless, it is human nature to be self-centered. It is part of what keeps us motivated. We want to work hard and get good jobs because we want to take care of our loved ones and ourselves. Self-centeredness also keeps us alive and healthy. A doctor who spends all of his time seeing patients but not taking care of his own physical and emotional needs will eventually burn out.

I always struggled with the idea of putting my volunteer experience on my resume/CV. I felt like I was using other people to accomplish my own goals which really made me question my motives. Am I helping others because I genuinely care about them or because I need to get into medical school? The true answer may not always be so black or white, as the world is not black or white. I could help people because I care about them but also because it serves me a purpose. Does that make my service less genuine? I think we all need to decide that for ourselves.

||Read: Truth and Compassion in Medicine||

Both in college and medical school, as I look at my own tendencies and at the habits of my peers (premedical and medical students), I’ve noticed something very disturbing. When a colleague or even my close friend does well on a test, receives an award or a prestigious fellowship, or becomes the leader of a club/organization, I couldn’t help (in my own mind) to make their accomplishments about me.

Why didn’t I do as well on the exam?
I applied to the fellowship too, why didn’t I get it?
I would have made a much better coordinator them him.

It’s disappointing to know that so often, these were my first reactions rather than simply being happy for my classmates. To be honest, this is something I struggle with to this day.

The issue of self-centeredness is not necessarily clear-cut. Focusing on your own needs and wants is very important as well. For example, let’s say that you want to be a doctor but instead of studying for any exams, all you do is serve the homeless and volunteer at the hospital. Although your selflessness is admirable, if you don’t take care of your own needs in this scenario, it will prevent you from ever becoming a doctor.

So when does self-centeredness become pathologic? I cannot clearly define the criteria, but I know it when I see it. It often happens when my view of myself depends on what I do and what I’ve done. As a future doctor, I refuse to be defined only by my career, accomplishments and personal success. I personally don’t feel comfortable when I’m jealous of somebody when instead I should be happy for him or her. I know that looking at other peoples’ successes and feeling inadequate is not healthy.

||Read: Identity Outside of Medicine||

Once again, self-centeredness is human nature. It’s not necessarily a bad thing. But when my natural instinct of self-centeredness becomes pathologic and tries to define how I react towards other people’s accomplishments and goals, I must try to fight against it. I’ll stop defining my worth myself by my or others’ successes. When those around me succeed, I will celebrate with them rather than use that opportunity to criticize myself. I will remind myself of how thankful I should be to be the current position I am in. At the end of the day, who cares if you become a doctor, go to the best medical school or become a world-renown physician? I think sometimes all we can do is sit back, enjoy the ride that we’re on and appreciate the people around us that are also riding this roller coaster we call life.

The post A Future Doctor’s Greatest Struggle appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Connect With the Patient Behind the Disease https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/connect-with-the-patient-behind-the-disease/ Wed, 07 Jan 2015 23:56:08 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3214

It wasn’t until the 8th slide of the lecture that I began to feel uncomfortable. I fidgeted in my seat a bit as I stared at the presentation outlining the typical symptoms of IBD. It would only be several days later, during a conversation with a close friend, that I would truly understand the source …

The post Connect With the Patient Behind the Disease appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

It wasn’t until the 8th slide of the lecture that I began to feel uncomfortable. I fidgeted in my seat a bit as I stared at the presentation outlining the typical symptoms of IBD. It would only be several days later, during a conversation with a close friend, that I would truly understand the source of my unease. My complex experience as a Crohn’s disease patient had been reduced to a few words on a PowerPoint slide. Granted, I understood the necessity of it. There is simply not enough time in the medical school curriculum to dive into all of the social, psychological, emotional, and physical consequences of each and every disease we come across during our training. Even understanding this though, it still felt… wrong. Incomplete.

||Read: Personal Statements and Emotional Topics||

I thought back to all of the diseases I had learned about over the past year and a half. I had studied them religiously, committing the relevant physiology, symptoms, methods of diagnosis, and treatment to memory. And yet, how often had I stopped to consider that somewhere in the world, someone was suffering from one of the debilitating, life-altering, earth-shattering conditions I had learned about? How often had I truly considered what the word “pain” meant for someone, or how that might adversely alter his or her day-to-day life? Even being a patient myself, I had failed to connect with the patient behind the disease.

During the first two years of our medical training, there can be an emotional disconnect with the patient experience as we garner the basic knowledge necessary to become competent physicians. I am fortunate, like many of my medical school colleagues, to attend an institution that stresses the complex issues we will face as physicians, including empathizing with our patients. I am thankful that my medical school insists on having patients come in to speak with us about how they are coping with their diagnosis, even though it is often a painful topic to discuss. Such intense moments of unvarnished emotion are truly a precious gift, one that cannot be garnered from any textbook or set of lecture notes. They have, at times of extreme stress and fatigue, reignited my flame and passion for medicine.

||Read: Develop Compassion Before Medical School||

It is never too early for us to learn the importance of human connection and the necessity of compassion. Even though I am still in my pre-clinical years, it is important for me to remember that diseases are not an abstract idea. It is up to me to remember to pause periodically and reflect on the conditions I’ve learned. More importantly, however, it is my responsibility to remember that behind the diseases we so painstakingly put to memory, is an individual that suffers.

Parrisha Martelly is a 2nd year medical student at the Charles Drew/David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of ProspectiveDoctor.

The post Connect With the Patient Behind the Disease appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Medical Interview Perspectives: Pharmaceutical Tactics https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/medical-interview-perspectives-pharmaceutical-tactics/ Thu, 27 Nov 2014 01:08:29 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/pdr2/2014/01/10/interview-perspectives-pharmaceutical-tactics/

By Evan Laveman and Larry Laveman For other tips on medical interviews look at these related articles || How To Prepare for a Medical School Interview |  Common Interview Mistakes | 10 Articles to Prepare for Med School Interviews | How to Prepare for a Medical School Interview || The big business of drug revenue is constantly being fed by new and inventive ways of …

The post Medical Interview Perspectives: Pharmaceutical Tactics appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

By Evan Laveman and Larry Laveman

For other tips on medical interviews look at these related articles || How To Prepare for a Medical School Interview |  Common Interview Mistakes | 10 Articles to Prepare for Med School Interviews | How to Prepare for a Medical School Interview ||

The big business of drug revenue is constantly being fed by new and inventive ways of creating markets for drugs to affect. This inventive marketing strategy was developed by SmithKline (today known as GlaxoSmithKline), a British pharmaceutical company, to market their depression drug Paxil in 1991. It has since been adopted by many other pharmaceutical companies, including Pfizer in marketing Viagra, and Merck in marketing Zostavax, their drug for Shingles. It’s a very effective strategy, contributing to over 4 billion total prescriptions being written in 2012 and drug spending topping $320 billion. At the time of Paxil’s release in 1991, it was the third drug to get FDA approval in the category of SSRI’s (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors) to treat depression. The breakthrough drug was Prozac in 1986, followed by Zoloft in 1990. By the time Paxil hit the marketplace, Prozac and Zoloft were already dominating the space, so SmithKline came up with a unique advertising campaign designed to market a relatively low incident disease called social anxiety disorder (SAD) by establishing the disease as a major disorder that could be treated by Paxil. The strategy worked brilliantly, resulting in the immediate expansion of the SSRI market.

Prior to 1991, social anxiety disorder, and it’s close cousin, generalized anxiety disorder (GAD), were rare maladies in the category of anxiety disorders. With the marketing campaign in full swing, and billboards displaying the slogan, “Imagine Being Allergic to People,” SmithKline was busy getting the FDA to reassign its use of Paxil from a depression medication to an anti-anxiety medication. Given that it generally takes a new drug 8 years to win FDA approval, yet less than 18 months once approved to be reassigned for a new indication, Paxil’s application for reassignment gave SmithKline plenty of time to market the disease to match the drug. Within one year of its new designation Paxil outpaced Zoloft in sales.

In a completely different segment of the marketplace, Viagra was in development as a hypertension medication when researchers found that one of the side effects was increased blood flow to the penis, causing erections in men who were previously impotent. With its drug trials as a hypertension medication lacking efficacy, Viagra was specified as an erectile dysfunction (ED) medication in 1998 and brought to market. Viagra was the first oral medication for ED, but the potential market was small, mostly limited to the elderly and those suffering from diabetes or complications from prostate surgery. Pfizer’s marketing strategy was to expand the demand for Viagra by associating erectile dysfunction with even transitory or situational dysfunction by promising to make fully functional erections even better. The genius of the Pfizer marketing campaign was that it not only treated an entire category of men suffering in silence from ED, it also became a cultural game changer by extending the market, and the conversation, into all segments of the population including women.

Once marketed as a lifestyle drug, anyone with even the slightest loss of erectile strength were candidates for Viagra. Paxil and Viagra ushered in a new era of disease marketing that has caused the incidence of SAD and GAD to skyrocket from less than 2% of the population in 1990 to more than 10% of the population in 2011 and, in the case of ED, estimates are as high as 52% of all men over 40 currently experiencing some form of the disease.

More recently, Merck’s commercial for Shingles clearly demonstrates how marketing the disease, not the drug, is an effective strategy. The commercial begins with a retired firefighter earnestly talking about unexpectedly getting red sores on his skin followed by an extreme burning sensation. “It was like somebody had set a bag of hot charcoal on my neck,” he says. There’s a pause and then a voice over says that if you’ve had the chickenpox, the Shingles virus is already inside you. That gets your attention since 98% of the population of the United States has had this Varicella virus inside them since their childhood chickenpox episode. The firefighter, now present again and equally solemn, says in a slow determined voice, “It is bad. It’s something you never want to encounter.” The voice over then directs the viewer to “The Inside Story” at shinglesinfo.com.

The website is sponsored by Merck, the developer of Zostavax, an injection to protect you against Shingles. The vaccine has demonstrated efficacy in people over 60 years old in preventing the virus from being reactivated, making it a good preventative treatment for Shingles. The problem is that the vaccine isn’t selling, either due to spotty insurance coverage or its $300 price tag, so Merck began to market the disease. A careful reading of the website shows that you do not have to have chickenpox to get Shingles. There is no cure. There is no guaranteed treatment. There’s no known reason why some people get it and some do not. The vaccine can actually give you Shingles. And the vaccine only increases your chances of avoiding the onset of shingles, it does not prevent it. Other side effects can be extreme allergic reactions that include difficulty breathing and swallowing. By not mentioning the drug in its commercials about Shingles, Merck is exempt from using the requisite disclaimers required by the FTC when selling prescription medicine on TV.

Just as SmithKline did in its marketing campaign for Paxil, Merck was able to sidestep the disclaimer issue entirely by marketing the disease, not the drug. The drug is never mentioned. The side effects are never mentioned. Nowhere in the commercial or the website does it explain why only one third of the 98% of people who have had chickenpox get Shingles and what makes them so different as to be susceptible. Once the disease is established, and the majority of people have it or are susceptible to it, the sales of the medication to alleviate the disease soars. Shingles is “bad” and something that no one “ever wants to encounter.” All of this is true, but in the context of marketing the disease, it is also deceptive.

Drugs such as Paxil, Viagra and Zostavax create a world where there is no normal, only an exaggeration of symptoms that require prescription medication to alleviate your risk and/or symptoms. In some cases a normal category, such as SAD, is abstracted into an abnormal category so it can be treated by a specific medication. According to the drug companies, everyone is suffering from something that there’s a treatment for, even if it’s normal suffering or suffering that will remit on its own. Furthermore, if you’re normal there is another drug that can make you even better. These are called “lifestyle drugs” and in the case of Viagra, you can be even better than before even if you didn’t have a prior problem. This market is bolstered by a social response to diseases that were of little consequence until they were expanded and exploited by companies like Merck, SmithKline and Pfizer. During a time when healthcare costs already threaten to financially cripple so many families, it is important to keep an educated perspective on disease advertising and retain some of our diagnostic autonomy in making decisions about the medications we take.

Complex topics such as the role of business in medicine and pharmaceuticals are interesting ways of developing your own understandings of the field that may allow you to really shine in your medical interview.

This article was first posted on LarryLaveman.com

 

Larry Laveman is a licensed clinical social worker (LCSW) and board certified diplomate (BCD) who owns a private practice in San Diego and is the former chief clinical director for Harmonium, Inc., a nonprofit community based agency.

 

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of ProspectiveDoctor

The post Medical Interview Perspectives: Pharmaceutical Tactics appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Reflections on the First Year of Medical School https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/reflections-on-the-first-year-of-medical-school/ Thu, 13 Nov 2014 07:09:45 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3083

It’s almost been a full (calendar) year since medical school began. I’m officially a second-year medical student — and this year’s been a momentous one. As I look back on it, here’s some of my reflections on the first year of medical school. Fire hose: Med school really is like a firehose you’re supposed to drink …

The post Reflections on the First Year of Medical School appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

It’s almost been a full (calendar) year since medical school began. I’m officially a second-year medical student — and this year’s been a momentous one. As I look back on it, here’s some of my reflections on the first year of medical school.

Fire hose: Med school really is like a firehose you’re supposed to drink from. It’s high pressure, it’s intense, it’s humanly impossible to get it all down your throat. The idea is that you gulp, swallowing big but manageable amounts and manage to just keep drinking. That’s the challenge.

Intelligence may not help you. If you’re one of those people who managed to get through physical chemistry class napping, or didn’t have to freak out about biochemistry, or immunology in college, you’re probably going to have a tough time in med school. ‘Cause no matter how smart you are, there’s no way of intuitively getting a lot of the material that you’re supposed to learn. A lot of it’s just good old-fashioned memorization. And you might as well resign yourself to having to learn to actually work — because the material may be made easier by your intelligence, but you’ll have to learn to work really hard in a disciplined manner — which for me has been terribly challenging.

Big fish, big pond: Everyone in medical school will be a copy of you. Some will be better copies of you. One of my classmates, went for a 10 mile (I think) run, before taking his MCAT. A group of them get up every morning to practise crossfit before coming to class. Others still, run half marathons, or teach part-time, or design prostheses, or are involved in every single thing at the school. Prepare to deal with a lot of people who may do things you do — and to your mind — better than you can do them. That’s the idea of moving from where you were the best (or the only one) to being a group that has an MCAT average of 512 and a GPA of 3.8.

Find your bliss: Med school’s not nice to you (scratch that – life’s not going to be nice to you). It’s important to find what you love to do, your anchor to sanity and stress release and make it a part of your routine. For me, that’s exercise. If I don’t go to work out for a couple of days, I start feeling a little down. For other classmates (who are musically gifted, unlike my tone-deaf self), it’s music. For others, it’s running, or cooking, or playing with their dogs or significant others. It doesn’t matter what it is — just find what you need and do it regularly.

Open up: Med school seems to foster this intense belief that you need to hide your feelings as weakness that your classmates will use against you. Firstly, if that’s true, you go to a terrible med school. Secondly, nine times out of ten, what you’re feeling is common to a majority of your classmates. Try to share and see — you may be surprised.

Social life: They say you can’t have a social life in medical school. They say a lot of things. They’re wrong. It’s important to have one — it’s essential to your state of mind, and it’s easy to do. Just don’t make your social life the center of your existence, and you’re good. For example, I go out for meals with friends fairly regularly. I go visit people when I can, and I go do fun things when I can.

Time is short: I started med school a somewhat different person than I am today. Who didn’t. I specifically mean in terms of a willingness to do stupid things. Let me explain. I started, not averse to, but not searching for adventure. Now, I’m setting up skydiving plans for the end of the summer. I’m hosting a Thanksgiving dinner at my house (it’s adventurous because I’ve never made a roasted turkey), I’m trying to make international trips when I can, to see the world when I can.

Live with someone: I’m someone who needs a degree of human contact from time to time. That’s called being a human being. Some people are capable of managing without any for a week at a time. Hats off to them — I can’t do that. So, I suggest living with someone. You can choose someone in med school or not. Pros are that they’re not going to throw a party the night before the anatomy final, unless they’re really fun. They’re going to get your stress, and you can help each other out. Cons are, they’re in med school. You need friends from outside of med school. I live with a classmate, and it’s great, but in that situation, find people not in medicine you can connect with.

Be better: Every day of your life, you should be better than the day before. It sounds exhausting. But it’s important. So, this summer, I’m learning to cook a few more dishes than I have in the past, as well as continuing to try to get into shape. Find what you’re weak at, or want to be better at, and go.

Don’t get doughy: I say this with the conviction of being a recovering Pillsbury Dough Boy. I started college, and over the course of college, put on 60 pounds. The first year of med school I lost 20 of those. A lot of my classmates gained instead. Med school’s stressful, and we all like to stress eat. So, try to exercise, stock up on healthy food, don’t eat at every pizza thing the school does.

Prepare to be poor: I’m going to graduate medical school $250,000 or more in debt. Accept that, and chant it to yourself. It’s not meant to scare you, and you’re meant to push it to the back of your mind. It makes failing out of med school an expensive proposition but they actively work to prevent that. Still, that leads me to…

…but don’t live like a pauper: Since you’re going to be $250,000 in debt, at least live a little bit. Don’t subsist on Ramen noodles and water, and don’t live in a cardboard box. But, at the same time, no need to mistake yourself for a Rockefeller. Moderation in all things, as Petronius said. Still, sometimes a nice dinner at a nice restaurant, with a good bottle of wine can make a week. Just saying.

Sarab Sodhi is a fourth year medical student and masters in urban bioethics candidate at Temple University School of Medicine.

Reposted with permission from in-Training.

In-training

in-Training is the online magazine for medical students. It is the agora of the medical student community, the intellectual center for news, commentary, and the free expression of the medical student voice. All articles on in-Training are contributed by medical students around the world and are edited by its staff of volunteer medical students. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Tumblr, or email us to get involved.

The post Reflections on the First Year of Medical School appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
The Value of Being Curious https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/the-value-of-being-curious/ Fri, 17 Oct 2014 00:11:45 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=2900

It was always funny to hear other pre-meds talk about the application process as if they were already in or as if they knew what each admission committee was thinking. I would hear from others “You have to find your passion, you have to do this and that to show you care… you have to …

The post The Value of Being Curious appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

It was always funny to hear other pre-meds talk about the application process as if they were already in or as if they knew what each admission committee was thinking. I would hear from others “You have to find your passion, you have to do this and that to show you care… you have to prove that this is for you.” And yet, the truth is, I still don’t know what I am doing most of the time and I think I got into a pretty good medical school.

I think the biggest part that bothered me about the application process was that there were expectations that following a certain set of criteria would get you in. I don’t dismiss the fact that you need to do well in school and there are certain things that need to be done to show interest in medicine. But the part that I didn’t always hear from people was an honest admission that maybe we don’t have it all figured out. And that isn’t necessarily a bad thing.

Maybe it is just me, but I don’t always believe the answer lies in knowing exactly what you are doing (talk to me again when I get malpractice insurance), but rather being curious about what you don’t know yet. For me, the person who is more curious always beats out the person who might have known more at the outset. Hard work beats talent when talent doesn’t work hard. Something like that.

I used to listen to stories of people who had done x, y, and z and found myself in awe. I admired people who had 10.0 GPAs and built orphanages in Africa. Yet, I realized that I wasn’t going to be able to live up to those expectations. Eventually I understood that this isn’t a bad thing. In fact, that’s the best part.

Certainly we need people to admire and look up to, but that doesn’t mean that we are going to fail if we can’t live up to the image of the people we admire. On top of that, we all have our own stories to mold that are amazing in their own right. Spin anything a certain way and you can captivate anyone.

What I am trying to say is that you don’t need to have all of the answers now. Don’t feel overwhelmed by everything around you. Obviously, to get into medical school and succeed, you need to work hard and figure out the details of the application process so that you’re well-prepared. But this doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t make time to laugh and have fun. Get to know your friends. Not just through clubs, but over beers or something that doesn’t have to do with school. Know how to talk to people who aren’t in the same position as you. Learn how to really laugh and care for others not because it looks good on a resume or because someone else is watching. Strangely enough, doing the right thing is oddly undervalued. Do the right thing because it’s the right thing to do; seems simply enough right?

At the end of the day, don’t be afraid to put your guard down. Don’t be afraid to admit that you don’t know what’s going on. It’s strangely comforting. Not everyone is a prodigy, but that is alright. You’re just as cool and special as everyone else. Seriously.

Have fun and good luck!

 

Jeff Fujimoto is a second year medical student at the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA.

The post The Value of Being Curious appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
End Pre-Med Culture https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/end-premed-culture/ Fri, 26 Sep 2014 18:00:00 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=2827

What is the first thing you think about when you think of the word “premed”? Chances are that your initial thoughts are not good. Unfortunately, premeds have gained the reputation of being competitive, know-it-all, neurotic, selfishly ambitious, annoying, etc. When I was a premed, I even judged other premeds for being overly premed (I am …

The post End Pre-Med Culture appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

What is the first thing you think about when you think of the word “premed”? Chances are that your initial thoughts are not good. Unfortunately, premeds have gained the reputation of being competitive, know-it-all, neurotic, selfishly ambitious, annoying, etc. When I was a premed, I even judged other premeds for being overly premed (I am officially using premed as an adjective with negative connotation now). Although not every premed is like that, premed culture is not necessarily the friendliest one. The worse part is, as these premeds become medical students, they recreate the premed culture in medical school. This vicious cycle continues on as they transition from medical school to residency and eventually into full-fledged practice – once a crazy premed, always a crazy premed.

Premeds’ negative characteristics stem from taking some of their positive characteristics too far. For example, being ambitious is a great quality. Nevertheless, being ambitious to the point of harming your relationships with others is bad. Being knowledgeable is a good; being a snobby know-it-all is bad. So why do premeds allow their good qualities to become bad qualities? My theory is that this transition happens when we fail to understand our primary reason for why we want to become doctors.

||Read: Identity Outside of Medicine||

In the journey through medicine, it is very easy to let peripheral outcomes take center stage. These are the many great side things that come with being a physician. Respect, status, and above-average compensation are just a few. Nevertheless, these side things are “side” motivators for a reason. Physicians should not become physicians for these side things. At the heart of medicine are compassion, integrity, teamwork, and a genuine desire for knowledge. These are primary. Physicians should become physicians because they want to serve humanity with integrity and scientific acumen.

||Read: Why Should I Volunteer?||

You do not have to be a doctor to be compassionate, honest, and hungry for knowledge. Premeds can grow and nurture these characteristics as well. Rather than focusing on getting into the highest ranked U.S. medical school (or maybe even simply getting into medical school), premeds should focus on becoming great people who are genuinely excited about medicine. Premeds are trainees; the way they train affects how they will practice medicine in the future. If you only care about your personal goals as a premed, you will most likely care primarily about yourself as a physician. The temptation to let side things become primary gets more and more difficult to resist as you move up the hierarchy of medicine. As a medical student, sometimes I find myself letting side things define me: extracurricular activities I am involved in, exam scores, USMLE step 1, what residency I want to get into, etc, etc. I also catch myself comparing myself to my classmates in a negative way. When I start doing these things, I have to go back to my roots and remember why I am in medicine in the first place. And most of those roots were planted during my time as a premed. That is why I think that fostering the right attitude, as a premed, is so important.

||Read: Develop Compassion Before Medical School||

I am not saying that we shouldn’t look out for ourselves as doctors. I am saying that we shouldn’t only look out for ourselves. Do not put down others so that you can achieve your goals. Achieve goals together. Do not cry and complain when you do not get the grade or MCAT score you want; your career is not everything and you are not defined by it. Rather use the qualities that make premeds, and ultimately doctors, so great to bless others and achieve your goals in an honest, respectable way. Only then, we can end premed culture.

The post End Pre-Med Culture appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>