Emily Singer, Author at ProspectiveDoctor The premier resource for future doctors. Wed, 15 Feb 2023 23:11:13 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.1 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/cropped-pdr-favicon-rounded-1-32x32.png Emily Singer, Author at ProspectiveDoctor 32 32 The Medical School Dream https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/medical-school-dream/ Thu, 12 May 2016 00:54:39 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=4167

“My dream is to get into medical school and become a doctor.” This line is repeated in some form or another many times during application season. Most applicants do not know how truly dreamlike the experience is, particularly during third and fourth year clinical rotations. The first two years of medical school are consumed by …

The post The Medical School Dream appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

“My dream is to get into medical school and become a doctor.” This line is repeated in some form or another many times during application season. Most applicants do not know how truly dreamlike the experience is, particularly during third and fourth year clinical rotations.

The first two years of medical school are consumed by learning. Though there is little classroom time the shear volume of material that we have to digest requires incredible time and energy. Much is new – anatomy lab, histopathology, complex disease mechanisms – yet the fundamental skills of being a student – studying, giving presentations, taking exams – are familiar. These first two years can feel like an extension of undergrad, and you wait desperately to get to the meat of medical school when you transition from building knowledge to developing skills. Third year is where the dream – at least for me – begins.

In dreams we can do the impossible moving freely through time and space, unbound by the confining laws of “reality.” Time takes on new character, speeding up or slowing down without regard to the passing seconds on the clock by our bed. Emotions manifest on a different scale entirely, reaching new peaks and troughs as our subconscious allows us to explore how we truly feel about something. We wake up exhilarated, relieved, or confused – sometimes in awe of the capacity of our own minds.

Third year has given me incredible opportunities to participate in the care of other human beings: Diagnose, treat, cut, console, and palliate – all of these are in the purview of clinical rotations. The breadth of clinical experience spans caring for people at all ages and stages of life and our own emotional responses to witnessing the miracle of one family welcoming a new baby and the devastation of another being stripped of a loved one. Such extremes are rarely faced in day-to-day life, but are constants in both dreams and medicine.

On a day-to-day basis, you chance slipping into your own state of altered consciousness. Sleep deprivation, stress, and the rush of new experiences all contribute. Your days include incredible highs from acquiring a new skill, clinching a diagnosis, and making a true contribution, and profound lows from making an error, not knowing an answer, or losing a patient. Then, there are the moments that you wake up – either relieved by a day off when your alarm does not rouse you before the hour of 4 or 5am, or in a panic – you have overslept, forgotten something.

The first two years of medical school are challenging in their own right – you must acquire a tremendous amount of knowledge in a short time. During the third and fourth years you must apply this knowledge to the care of real patients under the supervision of residents and watchful eyes of attending physicians. Every step you take is into uncharted territory, and – though you have the guidance of some excellent mentors along the way – each wrong step is observed. If you have ever dreamt that you were standing naked in a public space – well the third year of medical school can sometimes feel like this.

I knew going in that there would be many demanding rotations. What I did not realize was how much they would infringe on my time and mental energy outside of the hospital. With rounds on certain rotations starting at 6am (meaning prerounding at 5am) and the days sometimes ending after 10pm, there was little time family, exercise, good nutrition, or sleep. Most inpatient rotations are six days per week and on several occasions I was without a break for 15 days in a row. I was often still mentally at the hospital when I was home, distracted by a clinical question or stressed about rounds the next day. Putting it mildly I was less than good company to my husband and dogs. At my darkest moment, I woke up lodged in the bumper of the car in front of me, thankfully from a low speed in stop-and-go traffic, but with the terrifying realization that I could have totaled a human in place of my Honda. My experiences in the hospital were mostly good, but one great day delivering a baby with an attending was followed by her shaming me the next for a mistake during rounds in front of ten residents.

On the other hand, there were moments of pure bliss. I realized I wanted to be a surgeon, and one whom I idolize agreed to mentor me; I was trusted to make incisions, sew on viscera, and close skin; I accompanied the lead surgeon to tell a family that surgery had gone well; my patient grabbed my hand and thanked me for being there. There were moments when the theoretical knowledge of the first two years suddenly takes on new dimension and meaning when applied to human beings – those indescribably satisfying “clicks” of new synaptic connections forming in your own brain. Upon your consciousness settles the realization that you are becoming more skilled, knowledgeable, and capable every single day.

I am grateful for the experiences prior to medical school that helped me develop a certain level of resilience. Living in a foreign country, working for a tough boss and tougher clients, getting multiple med school rejections, going through break-ups, losing loved ones unexpectedly – the list of grit-building exercises goes on and on. The challenges I have overcome prior to medical school have helped me keep the occasional nightmares of third year in perspective.

If you choose to pursue your medical school dream, then I encourage you to come to terms with the waking reality. Consider your own ability to rebound after a psychic challenge. Medical school, residency, fellowship – these are not static means to an end – they are part of the dream with all of its emotional swings and guaranteed terrors. That said, I will not stop going to sleep fearing a nightmare. Indeed, when I crawl under the covers and turn out my light I am hopeful that tonight I will fly.

The post The Medical School Dream appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
15 Books for Medical School Applicants https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/15-books-medical-school-applicants/ Wed, 21 Oct 2015 08:13:15 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3094

I am frequently asked how to prepare for medical school interviews. As many schools are moving to the multiple mini interview (MMI) format, a lot of interviewing well involves thinking on your feet and efficiently articulating your perspective. One of the best ways to prepare for medical school interviews, (and in fact a career in …

The post 15 Books for Medical School Applicants appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

I am frequently asked how to prepare for medical school interviews. As many schools are moving to the multiple mini interview (MMI) format, a lot of interviewing well involves thinking on your feet and efficiently articulating your perspective. One of the best ways to prepare for medical school interviews, (and in fact a career in medicine), is to read. The more you have read and thought about major issues in medicine (healthcare reform, end-of-life, medical mistakes, cultural sensitivity, gender identity, etc.) the better you will be able to intelligently discuss them in interviews. To help current and future applicants prepare, I thought I would share some of my favorite books about medicine with ProspectiveDoctor readers. Here is a list of my 15 books for medical school applicants:

  1. Better by Atul Gawande
  2. Complications by Atul Gawande
  3. Being Mortal by Atul Gawande
  4. Mountains Beyond Mountains by Tracy Kidder
  5. The Emperor of All Maladies by Siddhartha Mukherjee
  6. How We Do Harm by Otis Brawley
  7. Cutting for Stone by Abraham Verghese
  8. The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks by Rebecca Skloot
  9. The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down by Anne Fadiman
  10. The Death of Ivan Ilyich by Leo Tolstoy
  11. Musicophilia by Oliver Sacks
  12. The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat by Oliver Sacks
  13. The Diving Bell and the Butterfly: A Memoir of Life in Death by Jean-Dominique Bauby
  14. Mortality by Christopher Hitchens
  15. Hippocrates’ Shadow by David Newman

If you have other books about medicine that you would like to recommend to ProspectiveDoctor, please e-mail me at emilysinger@prospectivedoctor.com

Happy reading, everyone!

|| Read more about  The Multiple Mini Interview: What to Know | MMI Pitfalls | Weekly Weigh-In: Med School Interview Tips ||

The post 15 Books for Medical School Applicants appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Medical School Waitlist https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/medical-school-waitlist/ Mon, 25 May 2015 07:00:43 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/pdr2/2014/04/10/medical-school-waitlist/

Applicants across the country now await decisions from the medical schools that interviewed them. They spent thousands of hours, dollars, unquantifiable effort, and thought applying to medical school. In return, they yearn for a simple “yes” or “no.” I was inspired to write this article after receiving a very thoughtful request for advice from a …

The post Medical School Waitlist appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

Applicants across the country now await decisions from the medical schools that interviewed them. They spent thousands of hours, dollars, unquantifiable effort, and thought applying to medical school. In return, they yearn for a simple “yes” or “no.” I was inspired to write this article after receiving a very thoughtful request for advice from a reader who is currently in his third application cycle. I have wanted to write about “waiting” for some time, and now I will wait no longer.

I applied to and was waitlisted at three top-ten schools in three years. Two of those years, I was accepted nowhere. In April of the third cycle after being waitlisted at four of the five schools that interviewed me, I was finally accepted by UCLA two days before their “second look” weekend. For me, this story has a happy ending, however, I do not forget the agony of waiting. I believe that the psychological toll on applicants deserves some discussion.

||Read Emotional Intelligence in Medicine||

According to AAMC, in 2013 there were a total of 690,281 applications to medical school, resulting in matriculation for 20,055 students. Assuming, on average, that each student applied to 20 schools, there were approximately 34,500 applicants. This means that at least 40 percent of applicants did not matriculate into the class of 2017 at any one of the country’s 141 medical schools. (In fact, I have heard that as many as 50 percent of applicants are not offered even a single acceptance). When you look at your chances for getting into any particular school, the numbers become grimmer: one of the most competitive schools is Boston University with an acceptance rate of 1.4%, while far less competitive is South Dakota, which accepts a whopping 12.7% of its applicants.

||Read What Happens if I Get Waitlisted?||

I am reporting these numbers to remind you that the medical school admissions process is more challenging and competitive than anyone imagines, and, until you have gone through it, you may find it difficult to appreciate the full scope. If you are still waiting, give yourself a break and do not despair – you are in good company.

After my first failed attempt, I identified weaknesses in the content and timing of my submissions. After the second, other people started looking for holes in my application, and I began searching for personal deficits of character. The most devastating comment I received during this time was from a loved one: “If this doesn’t work out, then maybe it’s for the best and you will discover that you were meant to do something else – maybe this is not your dream.” I felt utterly inadequate as I watched peers get into competitive business and law schools. They were moving on and growing academically and professionally while I was stagnating in limbo. I was certain, however, that medicine was still, and would always be, my dream.

||Read How to Write a Letter of Intent & Example Letter of Intent||

While waiting, I felt my self-confidence receding. Paradoxically, it became more important but substantially more difficult to accept constructive criticism without taking it personally – projecting my own waning belief in myself onto those who were trying to help me improve my essays and prepare for interviews. I was afraid that my cheerleaders had grown weary after so many OTs, having been expecting a win by the end of regulation.

As my own cheerleader, it was hardest to rally for the next round of applications while still waiting to learn the outcome of the previous one. A waitlist that I was placed on in January would extend until classes started in August, while the next year’s application cycle would begin in June. I began reapplying, but the waitlist was a constant distraction, and getting accepted off the waitlist after reapplying would have meant that I had wasted time and money on the new submissions. I was ready to pick up and move for whatever school accepted me at the drop of a hat, take on incredible debt, and scrub the toilets of the admissions office if it meant that I would matriculate.

||Read Why Applicants Are Rejected from Medical School||

Looking back, it is hard to imagine going through that process again. I can only think of violent language to describe the waiting: I was “held hostage” by the admissions committees; I was “brutalized,” “demoralized,” and “worn down” by the delayed rejections I received as classes commenced at the schools for which I was still holding out hope. I nonetheless continued to hope, submitting application after application in cycle after cycle, and in the process I became more steadfast in my conviction to become a doctor.

||Read How to Get Off the Waitlist||

I wish I could say that waiting taught me patience, but in reality I simply had no choice but to wait. I was impatient and anxious, and if I became any less of either it likely had more to do with getting older. What I did acquire from this whole awful process however was the ability to bounce back after repeated failures – some might call it “grit.” When you consider qualities that you would like in your doctor, “grit” might not immediately come to mind. Framing it differently – you might relate better to a physician who understands what it feels like to struggle with and fail at something. You might also appreciate your doctor’s resolve not to give up in the face of hardship, especially if she is treating you for an aggressive recalcitrant disease.

For those of us that don’t make it the first time, grit is the desirable quality that emerges as an unintended outcome of medical school admissions. While the numbers seem to indicate that getting accepted is also an unintended consequence of the whole process, I am glad that I stuck with it. In the end, it was worth the wait.

||Read Emily’s Path Part 1: Why I Applied to Medical School & My Personal Statement||

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of ProspectiveDoctor. Follow ProspectiveDoctor on Twitter @ProspectiveDr

The post Medical School Waitlist appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Tips from a Medical School Admissions Officer https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/tips-from-a-medical-school-admissions-officer/ Tue, 03 Mar 2015 01:00:55 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/pdr2/2013/09/24/tips-from-a-medical-school-admissions-officer/

A student admissions officer from a prominent NE medical school helps elucidate the admissions process at his school. Process Overview At this particular school, members of the medical school admissions committee screen applications and assign a score, which conveys the level of desire to extend the candidate an interview. A second committee member then sees the …

The post Tips from a Medical School Admissions Officer appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

A student admissions officer from a prominent NE medical school helps elucidate the admissions process at his school.

Process Overview At this particular school, members of the medical school admissions committee screen applications and assign a score, which conveys the level of desire to extend the candidate an interview. A second committee member then sees the score and reads over the application again and assigns his or her own score. If the average of the two scores is above a certain cutoff, then the school extends an interview offer.

This medical school uses a traditional open interview format, consisting of two in-person interviews with members of the committee. The “open” format means that the admissions officer has read your application materials ahead of time.

At the admissions committee meeting the week following the interview, one of the two interviewers presents the candidate, providing information from the AMCAS and secondary written applications and interview, as well as personal impressions. Following the presentation, committee members assign the candidate a score, and the average score determines the candidate’s acceptance/rejection/waitlist status.

Details During the screening process, reviewers see GPA and MCAT scores first. Some reviewers, (including the one Prospective Doctor interviewed), will try not to look at these scores before contextualizing them by looking at your undergraduate institution, major, and activities.

The initial screening score is thrown out – the admissions decision is based entirely on post-interview scoring by the committee. Therefore, the interview is critically important. The way your interviewer presents you to the committee impacts voting, so the impression that you leave is pivotal.

Tips from an Admissions Officer

  1. Be “well lopsided.” Try to be very strong in a few areas, rather than superficially involved in many. You should have experiences in leadership, research, and service, but certain cornerstones – such as being a varsity athlete or leading a major campus organization – will stand out, and could even make up for lower MCAT scores or GPA.
  2. Be specific in your secondary. Be sure to tailor your secondary to the school you are applying to, mentioning specific attributes and why those make you a good fit. A generic secondary shows a lack of effort.
  3. Get prestigious and/or superlative letters of recommendation. It helps if your letter writer is well known, particularly if he/she is from the institution to which you are applying; however, a more personal letter with superlatives (“…among the most intelligent,” “…one of the best students to come through my lab,” etc.) trumps an impersonal letter from an academic celebrity.
  4. Avoid lying and arrogance. Perhaps this seems obvious, but your written application should be a truthful representation of you and is subject to scrutiny in interviews. For example, if you list cooking as one of your activities, then your interviewer may ask you what you like to cook and how you prepare it. The activities you designate “most important” will likely be covered. Walk the line between being humble and confident when discussing any part of your application.
  5. Be excited. It is easier for the interviewer to connect with someone that is passionate about something and can talk about it at length. Your passion does not have to be strictly academic – it can be ballroom dancing or writing short stories, provided you are enthusiastic and knowledgeable about it. Be sure that you can articulate the things that you really care about.

The post Tips from a Medical School Admissions Officer appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Breaking Bad News https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/breaking-bad-news/ Tue, 10 Feb 2015 23:43:30 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3296

During a medical school interview, particularly in a multiple-mini-interview (MMI) format, you might be asked how you would go about breaking bad news to a patient. While this task might seem unfair to ask of a candidate medical student, it is no less daunting for me – now a second-year student, and in fact, for …

The post Breaking Bad News appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

During a medical school interview, particularly in a multiple-mini-interview (MMI) format, you might be asked how you would go about breaking bad news to a patient. While this task might seem unfair to ask of a candidate medical student, it is no less daunting for me – now a second-year student, and in fact, for practicing physicians.

This week, NPR reported about the challenges doctors encounter when discussing a cancer prognosis with a patient. Many, though not all, patients will want to know how long they have to live when faced with the often terminal cancer diagnosis. “How long do I have?”

Being able to answer this question gets to the very essence of the role of a doctor. As a scientist, a physician might tell her patient the median survival time, using data from the medical literature. Knowing that he is a critical source of comfort and support, the doctor might instead err on the side of optimism when discussing prognosis with his patient. There are problems with both of these approaches for patients, doctors, and their relationship.

Last year, my friend C was diagnosed with lung cancer. After discussing the prognosis with his oncologist, C was obsessed with “two months.” Whether the doctor told him that the median survival for his late-stage disease was “two months,” worst-case scenario was a “couple months,” or flat out said, “You have two months to live,” I will never know. What I do know is that, from that encounter forward, C was convinced that he had a definite expiration date, and no amount of explaining would allow him to let go of this idea that in T-minus two months he would be dead.

In fact, C lived about seven months, before finally succumbing to his disease at home last January. I was left with the uncomfortable notion that somewhere along the way communication between doctor and patient had failed my friend.

Though we all live with the uncertainty about when we are going to die, most of us feel like death is rather far off, and that we have some degree of control over our fate. By eating right, exercising, and getting enough sleep we can keep our bodies going like well-oiled machines. When, however, the body begins to malfunction on its own without external insult, we lose our sense control and are suddenly operating with an even greater deal of uncertainty. It unmasks the possibility that more might go wrong. It is no wonder then that cancer patients want to know when things will start to go wrong and how long they have left to live. More pragmatically, faced with a limited amount of time, patients must figure out what decisions they have to make and which of their goals they will be able to accomplish.

The problem with generating an estimate for a patient is that it rather artificially imposes certainty on an inherently uncertain and unstable process. Even after being told that “median” survival time means that half of people with the same cancer will live a shorter period and half a longer period, patients like my friend tend to understand the number as absolute, according to psychiatrist Tomer Levin, who works with cancer patients at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York. Therefore, doctors – with the good intent to inform patients that there is a range – are interpreted as giving a sentence.

Perhaps this is why most physicians (63%, according to a study published in the British Medical Journal) overestimate survival of terminally ill cancer patients. Knowing that patients will cling to any specter of certainty, doctors overshoot. In some cases perhaps it seems most humane to offer patients and their families hope. Among many physicians and non-physicians it is agreed that people with something to live for live longer: married men, for example, live longer than the unmarried, and “natural cause” deaths spike on Christmas, December 26, and New Years Day as if people were holding out to make it through the holidays. Perhaps physicians believe that high expectations can be self-fulfilling, and offering hope might actually extend life. However, by being overly optimistic you risk setting patients up for disappointment or the feeling of being cheated when they start to decline “early.”

Dr. Levin suggests giving patients the worst-case scenario, the best-case scenario, and the most likely scenario. This approach allows patients to hope for the best case, plan for the worst, and accept the uncertainty that they will likely fall somewhere in the middle.

I like this suggestion, and hope very much to employ it as I go forward in my career, however I know that my own first inclination is towards optimism. When confronted with the task of telling a standardized patient, (an actor posing in a hospital bed), with inoperable pancreatic cancer her prognosis in our Doctoring class, I was reluctant to use numbers at all, euphemistically telling her that she likely had “on the order of months” to live. I was quick to add that we did not know how long it would be, and it was possible that she might surprise us and live a lot longer. Though it was easier to plan for end-of-life “palliative” care after acknowledging the terminal prognosis, I was overcome with emotion realizing that she was the same age as my mother, (a reaction termed countertransference in psychiatry). This is to say that the duty of discussing prognosis is further complicated by the physician’s own emotional experience.

To make a gross generalization, doctors thrive on knowledge. Operating under uncertainty and admitting that there is a limit to your knowledge is uncomfortable. Additionally, most of us chose the profession to help people – we like being in a position of providing strength and comfort to patients and their families at vulnerable moments. Just as we must be aware that we are providing important information and hope to patients when we discuss prognoses, we must also be aware that quoting numbers from medical literature helps us feel like we can impose order in the face of uncertainty and being overly optimistic helps us cope with our own vulnerability to losing a patient. Our compassion is not reserved entirely for our patients, but is also operating in the interest of self-preservation.

There may not be a right way to break bad news, but rather it is a balancing act of tailoring science and compassion to the individuals on either end of the conversation. Therefore, when in medical school interviews and your future career you are confronted with breaking bad news, know that it is an art as emblematic of your role as a physician as providing life-saving treatment, and a skill upon which all physicians must strive to improve.

The post Breaking Bad News appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Brainstorming Your Personal Statement for Medical School https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/brainstorming-personal-statement-medical-school/ Fri, 16 Jan 2015 08:07:23 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3239

It is intensely difficult to write a personal statement, and perhaps the most difficult part is starting. What a daunting task to explain the answer to “Why I want to be a doctor”. Given the overwhelming nature of this question, many applicants make the mistake of answering a different question: “What have I done that …

The post Brainstorming Your Personal Statement for Medical School appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

It is intensely difficult to write a personal statement, and perhaps the most difficult part is starting. What a daunting task to explain the answer to “Why I want to be a doctor”. Given the overwhelming nature of this question, many applicants make the mistake of answering a different question: “What have I done that qualifies me to matriculate into medical school?” The result is a tedious personal statement that reads like a resume.

|| Read Personal Statements and Emotional Topics ||

Perhaps a better approach to starting the personal statement is not to focus on the question that your essay will ultimately answer, but on the personal aspects of your experiences on earth that shaped who you are – a person whose goals and values align with entering the medical profession.

|| Read The Formula for a Good Personal Statement ||

There is no algorithm for writing the perfect personal statement, but good ones tend to reveal something about the applicant’s personality as well as interests outside of medicine. You will have to decide what to reveal about yourself and how to weave in your motivation for the career. What I suggest however as you sit down to brainstorm, is that you do not start with all of your premed activities (research, volunteering, shadowing), but rather with a more fundamental list of experiences and people that helped shape you. Think about what each element on your list taught you or how it changed your trajectory or thinking. Answer for yourself why the event or person is important. Then, and only then, start trying to understand how one or two medically related activities ties in. This way, your personal statement will develop around a narrative that is unique to you, and will better communicate to admissions committees who you are and why you want to be a doctor.

|| Read Sample Personal Statement | Sample Non-Traditional Student Personal Statement ||

Here are some categories for brainstorming your personal statement for medical school:

Positive significant/formative life experiences: something that changed the course of your life, your activities, your outlook on the world, or made you think differently about your future

  • Learning to do something that lead you to excel in it/teach others/make a contribution (e.g., sports, science, foreign language, special skills)
  • Being given a second chance
  • Connecting with someone who made an impact on you
  • Being out of your comfort zone (experiences with people of different backgrounds, travel, moving, doing something for the first time)
  • Overcoming an obstacle

Challenging life experiences: something that forced a lesson upon you

  • A mistake you made
  • An event that was out of your control that nonetheless caused you suffering/loss

People that shaped your life

  • Mentor, parent, sibling, friend
  • Author, actor, speaker, personal hero

 

Best of luck, and happy writing!

The post Brainstorming Your Personal Statement for Medical School appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Dermatology – Maria Aleshin MD https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/dermatology-maria-aleshin-md/ Fri, 12 Dec 2014 23:13:41 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3185

10 Questions for a Doctor is a ProspectiveDoctor initiated interview series of physicians of various specialties. The goal of 10 questions is to gain learn more about different physicians, their specialties, and their reasons for going into medicine. Maria Aleshin graduated from the David Geffen School of Medicine, UCLA last year and matched into a Dermatology …

The post Dermatology – Maria Aleshin MD appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

MariaAleshin

10 Questions for a Doctor is a ProspectiveDoctor initiated interview series of physicians of various specialties. The goal of 10 questions is to gain learn more about different physicians, their specialties, and their reasons for going into medicine.

Maria Aleshin graduated from the David Geffen School of Medicine, UCLA last year and matched into a Dermatology residency at UCLA. She is currently in her medical internship year at Kaiser Permanent in Los Angeles.

When did you decide you wanted to become a doctor? What were your main reasons for going into medicine?

Medicine has been a part of my life since an early age. My mother was a doctor in Russia and would often bring my brother and me to the hospital on her evening shifts when she couldn’t find a babysitter. Some of my earliest childhood memories are from those nights. Naturally I wanted to follow in my mom’s footsteps and dreamed of becoming a doctor just like her one day. Although my desire to pursue a career in medicine stuck with me, it wasn’t until I got to college that I began to truly understand what it meant to be a doctor. In college I had the opportunity to explore medicine through various avenues; volunteering at hospitals, shadowing doctors, assisting in clinical research projects, and working at free clinics. These experiences showed me that doctors have an incredibly rewarding and versatile career. They not only are able to care for patients, but they can also mentor students and residents, lead cutting edge research projects, as well as help change policy (just to name a few). Seeing first-hand the numerous opportunities that a career in medicine holds, helped cement my desire to become a doctor.

How/why did you choose the medical school you attended?

I had heard a lot of great things about UCLA medical school before I applied, however it wasn’t until I visited UCLA that I realized that this school would be a great fit for me. The first thing that stuck out to me about UCLA was the people. Everybody, from the students to faculty, was extremely welcoming and went out of their way to be helpful. It was important for me to choose an institution where I liked the people; after all, I was going to be spending the next four years of my life working closely with them. The next thing that I really liked about UCLA was their pass/no-pass grading system. I had gone to UC Berkeley for undergrad and was ready for an environment which fostered collegiality rather than competition. I also liked that UCLA had an integrated systems-based curriculum, as opposed to the traditional curriculum which covers each subject separately (biochemistry, physiology, pathology, etc). UCLA also had less lecture time, which meant that students had more time to get involved in activities, ranging from leadership positions in on-campus groups, to volunteering in homeless clinics, to playing soccer with classmates. I was also drawn to UCLA because it is a large academic institution with numerous opportunities to get involved in basic science or clinical research. The last selling point was the location. Hard to beat 70 degree weather year round and a beach only 5 miles away from campus!

Describe your medical school experience. How hard was it to finance your education?

I feel as though I was extremely fortunate that I had the opportunity to attend medical school at UCLA. The four years I spent at UCLA were some of the most challenging, yet rewarding, years of my life. During the first year of medical school I spent most of my time getting to know my classmates and re-learning how to study, which was much more time-consuming than I had originally anticipated. By the time second year came around, I finally felt more comfortable simply being a medical student, and started to get involved both inside and outside of the classroom. I became involved in basic science research, coordinated a homeless clinic, volunteered at a women’s jail, and served as an officer of several on-campus groups. During my third and fourth year, I focused most of my energy on exploring the various fields of medicine.

Medical education isn’t cheap. The yearly tuition along with the cost of living in Los Angeles definitely leaves a pretty big dent in your pocket. Although I received a few scholarships from UCLA, they did not come close to covering all of my costs. I tried to save money wherever I could, however still had to take out a significant amount of money in loans.

How/why did you choose your medical specialty? Was there any part of your path to medicine that you would have done differently?

I was first introduced to the field of dermatology after attending a lecture at UCLA that discussed the role of immunotherapy in the treatment of melanoma. I had known people who had been affected by melanoma, as such was eager to learn more about this promising new therapy. This curiosity ultimately led me to the laboratory of a prominent leader in melanoma research. While in the lab I was able to work with individuals from numerous fields. The dermatologists I met encouraged me to come shadow them in order to gain a better sense of what the field of dermatology entails. These experiences, along with my long-standing interest in research and teaching, shaped my desire to pursue a career in academic dermatology.

What do you like about your job? What do you dislike?

I am currently doing my preliminary year of medicine at Kaiser Sunset Los Angeles. I just finished medical school and began working as an intern two months ago. It is both exhilarating and terrifying to finally be a doctor who is responsible for taking care of patients. The thing I enjoy most about my job is the variety. On any given day I can spend time talking to patients and their families, yet I also have the opportunity to perform procedures. I can also learn from fellow residents and attendings, yet I also can teach and mentor medical students. The thing that I dislike most about my job is the endless “paperwork.” I feel as though a great deal of time every day is spent in front of the computer writing notes, placing orders, etc. Although I know that proper documentation is extremely important, I feel as though it takes away from time that we could be spending with our patients.

Describe a typical day at work. How many hours do you work a week?

Our intern year is broken up into eleven blocks that are each four-five weeks in length. During one block we may be managing patients on wards, whereas another block we are cross-covering patients overnight, and another block we may be doing shift-work in the emergency room. Because each block is so different, it is hard to describe a typical day. However I will describe a typical day on wards since that is what most people associate with intern year. I typically come into the hospital around 6:30am to pre-round on my patients before going to morning report. Afterwards, the team rounds with the attending typically until noon. During lunch-time there is a noon-conference which is followed by floor work/note writing in the afternoon. Typically interns can sign out at 5pm if they are not on-call. When a team is on call, they typically stay until 9-10pm admitting new patients. During intern year, most residents work about 70-80 hrs/week.

How difficult is it to balance work and the rest of your life? Do you have any strategies on how to balance work and life outside of work?

As an intern I am working about 80 hours per week, which averages out to roughly 12 hours per day. Factoring in the commute, there is typically less than 11 hours left a day to sleep, eat, shower, run errands and “have a life.” As interns we spend countless hours focusing on the health of others, however we often neglect our own health. We stop working out, start eating poorly, and get hooked on caffeine to fight our sleep-deprived states. We start to spend less and less time with our family and friends, instead choosing to veg out in front of the TV. In order to survive intern year, we must fight against these poor habits. Because our time is limited, we must spend what little time we have on ourselves and our well-being. Whether that means going to the gym after work, or to the movies with your friends, or on a date-night with your significant other, we must make an effort to continue to do the things that make us who we are. Otherwise it becomes easy to lose yourself during intern year. We must surround ourselves with people who can support us during this difficult time. The most important thing to remember is that life doesn’t stop during residency. Although it becomes more challenging to manage your time, it’s important to remember to keep living your life.

Does your job allow you to have the lifestyle that you want?

Dermatology is largely an out-patient specialty, with most dermatologists working 8am-5pm, five days a week. Furthermore, dermatology is unique because it rarely has any after-hour emergencies. As such, it is one of the few fields in medicine where it is possible to work close to a 40 hour work week. This is why many people consider dermatology a “lifestyle specialty.”

What advice would you give to students who are interested in your specialty?

Dermatology is known for being a challenging specialty to apply into. As a medical student I often heard that a dermatology applicant must have stellar board scores, numerous first author publications, as well as all honors on their clinical rotations. It’s hard not to get discouraged after hearing such impossibly high standards. Dermatology is a rather small field with few programs nation-wide, therefore by default there are fewer spots for interested applicants. That’s not to say that if someone is interested in dermatology they shouldn’t apply. Rather, they must be prepared to work hard. I don’t know what the secret formula is for getting into dermatology, but I do know that through hard work and perseverance anything is possible. If a student knows that they are interested in dermatology, I would recommend that they get to know the faculty and residents at their medical school. They should try to shadow whenever they can or attend grand rounds, pretty much anything that shows that they are interested in the field. If the student has time and they are interested, they can get involved in some scholarly pursuit whether it be writing a review paper, case report, or being involved in bench research. Students should also excel during their clinical rotations. That’s not to say they need all honors, instead they should show a genuine interest in all aspects of medicine and demonstrate that they have good work ethic and that they work well with others. Lastly, the dreaded topic: board scores. The boards are a stressful time for every medical student, irrespective of what they are applying into. I would recommend that students try their best on the exam, however shouldn’t place all their eggs in one basket. One board score will not make or break their future careers. Rather it’s the whole package. I would strongly recommend that students interested in applying into dermatology find a dermatology mentor and talk to other students who have applied before them.

What advice would you give to people who are interested in becoming a doctor?

It seems as though applying for medical school becomes tougher and tougher every year. Although it’s easy to get discouraged, it’s important to remember what your ultimate goal is. If you truly want to be a doctor, you will make it happen! If you don’t succeed the first time, try again. Some small tidbits of advice for the application process. Apply early. Apply broadly. Finish secondary applications as soon as possible. Talk to people who have applied to medical school before you. Ask them what worked for them and what didn’t work. Surround yourself with friends and family that will support you through the application process. Be patient; the application process is a marathon, not a sprint. And lastly, don’t doubt yourself. The application process is a rollercoaster and there will certainly be ups and downs. Try not to get discouraged and keep your eye on your long term goal.

 

 

The post Dermatology – Maria Aleshin MD appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
A Parent’s Perspective https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/parents-perspective/ Wed, 19 Nov 2014 20:45:38 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3103

Dr. Jack Singer shares a parent’s perspective on his daughter’s medical school application process, which was not successful until the third attempt. His daughter, Emily Singer, is a member of ProspectiveDoctor’s core team and a frequent contributor to ProspectiveDoctor. After graduating Stanford with majors in economics and Slavic studies and working initially at a medical …

The post A Parent’s Perspective appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

Dr. Jack Singer shares a parent’s perspective on his daughter’s medical school application process, which was not successful until the third attempt. His daughter, Emily Singer, is a member of ProspectiveDoctor’s core team and a frequent contributor to ProspectiveDoctor.

After graduating Stanford with majors in economics and Slavic studies and working initially at a medical epidemiology consulting company and then as a chemist and regulatory affairs officer at commercial startup that marketed biologically derived anti-bacterial products, Emily made the decision to apply to medical school. She scored in the top 6% on her MCATs, despite not having taken some of the standard pre-med courses. She applied to a highly competitive MD/PhD program in economics at the University of Chicago and was waitlisted. Surprisingly, she failed to get other interviews on her first try, even at second-tier schools. She was accepted to the economics PhD program at the University of Washington, but chose to try again for admission to medical school. She was interviewed at several top tier schools on the second attempt but again was waitlisted. She was accepted at UCLA on the third go round, but again there was a surprising lack of interest from lesser programs and no apparent interest from the University of Washington, where my wife and I are on faculty.

My wife and I have had highly successful academic medicine careers. We are both Professors of Medical Oncology at the University of Washington and feel that medicine was the correct choice for us, despite the many painful changes it has undergone during our careers that have increased the difficulty of defining a personally fulfilling pathway in the profession. Although I believed Emily could become a superb physician, her background and abilities allowed for many attractive choices for a career outside of medicine. Emily did several things that assured me she would be an excellent physician and investigator during her pre-medical school career. While studying abroad in Russia, she conducted a study of the health impact of the effect of suddenly decreasing the availability of vodka and demonstrated from public health records that it had an almost immediate impact on mortality. While in Russia, she also developed a supportive and caring relationship with a young girl awaiting a scarce kidney transplant. After graduation, she participated in the safety analysis for the FDA that lead to Avandia withdrawal from the market. Each of these demonstrated the qualities important to physicians: caring, curiosity, and a scientific approach to important questions.

|| Read Emily’s Path Part 4: Doctor Parents ||

We had numerous discussions regarding the increasingly important role of economics and health care policy on the medical profession and alternate pathways for making important contributions other than training as an MD. As time went on, Emily made the decision that without clinical qualifications and understanding patient care, she would always be limited if she chose such a career without obtaining the MD first. My initial skepticism was related to the long and arduous path she had chosen and increasing dissatisfaction of physicians with changes in the practice of medicine dictated by forces out of their control. My approach to providing guidance to my children and has been to let them make their own decisions and when appropriate to challenge them but not to try to contravene them. Once I was convinced that medicine was Emily’s calling, I became very supportive and was blown away by her difficulties in obtaining admission.

Having your child follow your career path, in my case nearly 50 years after I entered medical school, made me revisit why I chose medicine and what the application process was like in comparison to the present. I still do not know what prompted me to change to premed in my junior year and apply to medical school. My exposure to medicine was limited to an old-school family GP (general practitioner), and I entered school with vague thoughts of becoming an analytic psychiatrist, something for which I am totally unsuited. I had done moderately well in an Ivy League college and had obtained a broad education avoiding all but one premed course. I had been a physics major and took organic chemistry over a summer to meet the minimal requirements, and only had to take a bizarre and very competitive comparative zoology course to qualify as a premed. I applied to about 12 schools, got into six second-tier institutions, and chose Downstate SUNY because it was essentially free with my NY State Regents scholarship. This program was solely based on MCAT scores and required attending a school in NY State. This is strikingly different than the process applicants today go through.

|| Read Emily’s Path Part 1: Why I Applied to Medical School ||

Given this background, it was a rude awakening when I realized what the process for medical admission had become as Emily went through it on three occasions. The first year she applied, I was almost sure she would get in to at least a second-tier school. I could not believe it when she was waitlisted at the University of Chicago, one of my Alma Maters, and did not even get interviewed elsewhere. This was our daughter who had been through a highly competitive private high school, had her choice of high profile colleges, did well a Stanford, had stellar MCAT scores, interviewed well, was very personable, and was a product of two academically well-known physicians. We realized fairly early on that any attempt on our part to influence the admissions process through our colleagues would not work but might even hurt her chances. Having two parents on the medical school faculty did not seem to help at the University of Washington, whose admissions committee  deigned to invite Emily for an interview during any of her attempts at admission. With absolute certainty, I feel I would have had no chance at admission in today’s environment given my somewhat mediocre college record. The same is true of many of my successful colleagues.

In retrospect, Emily did not demonstrate her desire to be a physician in her applications with sufficient intensity the first year. She applied somewhat late, had not taken optimal science courses to be competitive, and I suspect the schools sensed a lack of commitment in her applications. I also sensed some ambivalence on Emily’s part about whether this was the right path for her given many other easier and more lucrative opportunities available to her. Sensing that lack of total commitment, although disappointed at her not being accepted, I did not feel as badly as I did when she was not accepted during her second admissions attempt. For her third and successful round, she had taken and done well in upper division biology courses at UC Berkeley, had worked with academic mentors, driven up her MCAT scores even further, wrote a superb personal statement, and was accepted at a prestigious school that had not even interviewed her previously. She also developed a real interest in medical science and the caring aspects of medicine that I had not seen previously. This was the year she fully convinced me that she should become a physician and would become a real contributor to medical science.

|| Read Non-Traditional Student Personal Statement Example ||

Looking back on the process from a parent’s perspective, I feel that nothing we could have done differently would have had an influence on the process. The drive to become a physician and to make whatever sacrifices are necessary needs to be an internal one. Perhaps, as a parent, it may be useful to stand back and ask yourself, is this really what my child wants to do with their life? Are they really willing to go into debt, take on 6-8 years of onerous training, and sacrifice of personal time that it takes to become a physician? If the answer is affirmative, then the only advice I can offer is to be supportive as a child takes on this highly challenging process, of which the application is only the beginning.

The trials and tribulations of this process definitively ended at the White Coat Investiture ceremony on a beautiful day in LA. This was a very emotional event for Emily and our family and symbolized a major life transition. Emily was now entering the ancient “priesthood” of Medicine and would soon be not only our child, but also a colleague. There are still many choices to make and competitive hurdles to jump and I look forward to providing whatever support, advice, or assistance Emily needs in deciding on her own career pathway.

 

Dr. Jack Singer is a founder of CTI BioPharma and currently serves as the Company’s Executive Vice President, Global Medical Affairs and Translational Medicine. Prior to joining CTI, Dr. Singer was Professor of Medicine at the University of Washington and full Member of the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center. From 1975 to 1992, he was the Chief of Medical Oncology at the Veterans Administration Medical Center in Seattle. Dr. Singer received his M.D. from State University of New York, Downstate Medical College.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of ProspectiveDoctor. Follow ProspectiveDoctor on Twitter @ProspectiveDr

The post A Parent’s Perspective appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Weekly Weigh-In: Transition to Medical School https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/weekly-weigh-transition-medical-school/ Fri, 24 Oct 2014 02:27:28 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=2919

This week members of the ProspectiveDoctor team answer the question: “What was the hardest part about your transition into medical school?” The Social Scene The hardest part of the transition into first year for me was social. As strange as it sounds, med school feels a lot like high school again where you see the …

The post Weekly Weigh-In: Transition to Medical School appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

This week members of the ProspectiveDoctor team answer the question: “What was the hardest part about your transition into medical school?”

The Social Scene

The hardest part of the transition into first year for me was social. As strange as it sounds, med school feels a lot like high school again where you see the same people in class almost every day. I went to UCLA for undergrad and I got used to the idea of class being more “all-business.” I would just go to class and leave without really interacting with anyone. Therefore most of my close friends did not have class with me (none of them were my major). This gave me the flexibility to hang out with different people from different social groups. I wasn’t really in any one clique. Although I had a close group of friends, many of whom were my roommates, I felt like I had more time and opportunity to get to know more people outside of my regular social circle.

It feels completely different in med school. I see so many of the same people every day and most of my relationships with these people are unfortunately superficial. Even though I would like to get to know people more, I think everyone feels the pressure of “getting their work done,” so it’s hard to socialize at a deeper level. Also people naturally gravitate towards people similar to them. As a result, cliques develop a lot more easily. In the beginning of school, I found myself bouncing around between cliques because I had relationships with one or two people in each clique. But when I hung out with the entire clique, it would feel kind of awkward because I didn’t know all of them and they were already an established group of friends. I think that’s one aspect of first year that was really difficult for me. Thankfully I think I’ve able to find some balance between having close friends while also being open to new relationships, but it took more time and effort than if I were to have just been in one exclusive group of friends.

– Edward Chang

||Read Weekly Weigh-In: Qualities of a Successful Medical Student||

Saying “No” to Extracurricular Opportunities

Not necessarily the hardest part, but certainly a transitional process for me was realizing that schoolwork needed to come first, and that extracurricular activities wouldn’t play as large of a role in medical school as they did in college. It seems obvious that education and learning come first, especially to a premedical student, but in college I had the weakness of always saying yes to each opportunity. Volunteer to teach CPR courses? Yes. Work 15 hours a week in a research lab? Great! Shadow 6 hours a week in the Emergency Department? Sure! I found that I sometimes became overwhelmed with overcommitting, because every opportunity seemed too good to pass up. I found myself being spread thin across all my endeavors. Schoolwork and studying sometimes took a backseat to the extracurricular involvements in college. But hey, that was ok because not only was I getting great experiences, but these countless commitments were building my medical school application as well.

During my first year of medical school, I was advised by a close friend to not become over-involved like I had in college, because nothing was more important than gaining my medical education. I decided to limit myself to 2 interests that could serve as routine reliefs from studying in school. I first chose to volunteer at a street-side medical clinic once a week, and secondly to invest time into ProspectiveDoctor. With these two activities, I could invest adequate time into both and stay on top of my schoolwork at the same time.

– Evan Shih

||Read Weekly Weigh-In: Med School Interview Tips||

Going Back to School

As someone who had been out of school and working for a number of years, I found it really difficult to transition back into being a student. The hours I kept were essentially flipped: when I was working, I was committed to being in an office/lab for eight to ten hours per day, and my evenings were free. Now, I can choose whether or not to be in class during the day, and my evenings are anything but free. While I do not have to show up to the same place at the same time each day, I must instead have the self-discipline to study whether or not I attend lecture. In a way, I am my own boss, and acquiring the knowledge and skills to become a competent physician is my more-than-full-time job. When I was working the only preparation to come into the office was remembering to put on pants. In contrast, preparing for lab or small-group sessions requires background research on a particular organ or disease process or familiarizing yourself with a new skill, such as where to place your stethoscope when listening to heart sounds.

The hardest part of my transition to medical school was getting used to organizing my own time around studying, exercising, socializing, and sleeping. In my second year I am still trying to figure out how to best balance competing priorities, but at least now the growing pains have eased and the balancing act feels comfortable and familiar.

– Emily Singer

||Read Weekly Weigh-In: Med School Surprises||

Shaping My Own Education

The hardest part about transitioning into medical school was learning how to reprogram myself to get the right education, not just the education that would pass me through medical school. Once you’re accepted, it is up to you to decide what kind of doctor you want to become, and what you need to pursue to figure that out. It was hard to not think of school as a stressful proving grounds for the next level, In some ways I had to evolve beyond that and realize that it’s okay to value, say, an optional antibiotic resistance seminar over a neuro lecture that would be tested on. Many of my most educational moments that I’ve had in medical school were not part of any mandatory curriculum, they were when I went and shadowed in the ER, or attended that bioethics symposium, or went to a mobile clinic, or maybe even when I realized that I could now properly educate a friend that had come to be with a now obvious health question months ago.

It’s sometimes hard to remember how important these things are to pursue and involve yourself in, especially when there is always schoolwork to be done. One of my Emergency Physician mentors would always tell me, “you’re not going to hurt or affect anyone other than yourself on a silly exam,” and it’s true. I think I definitely take that for granted, but remembering that always calms me down for any exam, big picture. It’s okay to be a selfish in your pursuits, to be a doctor you’re forced to be selfish in many ways, but I’ve found it personally valuable to keep a perspective on the relative importance of the schoolwork in front of me, and the gravity of the situations that are slowly coming to the forefront.

– Evan Laveman

||Read Weekly Weigh-In: Favorite Aspect of Medical School||

The post Weekly Weigh-In: Transition to Medical School appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Truth and Compassion in Medicine https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/truth-compassion-medicine/ Tue, 07 Oct 2014 05:08:42 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=2861

You are standing naked in front of an auditorium of people wondering how you got there – you jolt awake, sweating, breathing hard – so relieved. But what if you did not wake up. What if you found yourself in front of 100 medical students, belly exposed, while your oncologist pointed out the damage that …

The post Truth and Compassion in Medicine appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

You are standing naked in front of an auditorium of people wondering how you got there – you jolt awake, sweating, breathing hard – so relieved. But what if you did not wake up. What if you found yourself in front of 100 medical students, belly exposed, while your oncologist pointed out the damage that cancer had wreaked on your spine?

||Read Emotional Intelligence in Medicine||

Several weeks ago, we learned about a “classical presentation” of multiple myeloma from a patient generous enough to share his story. A formal lecture on this disease, in which cancerous white blood cells accumulate in the bone marrow causing bones to break with little provocation, preceded the patient’s ten-minute talk about his experience with cancer. The lecture covered the details of multiple myeloma’s cellular and subcellular features, the “natural history” (how the disease progresses without treatment), and therapeutic strategies. In other words, we had a strong foundational understanding of the disease by the time the patient stood up to speak.

Mr. G is in his mid-sixties, but looks at least ten years younger. He has salt-and-pepper hair and a well-groomed beard. He wore a green polo and khaki shorts. As he began talking he reached into his pocket for a folded-up note he had written to “keep his story straight.” Looking up from the page, he mentioned that he had come alone because telling his story in the presence of his wife would bring him to tears – he did not want to cry in an auditorium full of students.

||Read Physician Shadowing and the One-Minute Mentor||

Like many people with multiple myeloma, Mr. G suffered broken ribs and multiple compression fractures (meaning that his vertebrae were being crushed by gravity) before his cancer was diagnosed. These fractures affected his posture and strength. When your bones break under the weight of your own body, it is difficult to do activities that build and maintain muscle. For a man who had led an incredibly active life, running a double-digit number of marathons, this disease prevented him from even washing dishes during a period after back surgery when he was confined to a wheelchair.

Just after Mr. G had described the corrective surgery to realign his lower back, his oncologist – our lecturer – lifted his polo without warning. Since Mr. G was facing us, his white belly was squarely exposed. The oncologist reoriented his patient into a profile view and pointed out the lingering kyphosis, or curvature of the back. “Stand up straight,” the doctor instructed. “You have a little bit of a kyphosis here (upper back) and a little bit of one here (middle back)… compared to most it’s pretty good.” Our lecturer let go of the polo and the shirt’s hem fell awkwardly down as the patient straightened it and continued his story.

||Read Personal Statements and Emotional Topics||

His telling was upbeat and forward-looking. At the insistence of his doctor, he mentioned his 32 rounds of chemotherapy, but preferred to tell us about the physical therapy, which has taught him to stand up straight and “do things that old people can’t do.” He even demonstrated several exercises for us. “Where your mind goes, your body follows,” he offered. He concluded by telling us that that in 2011 he thought he would “meet his maker” and today he is the best salesman at his company and that things could not be better.

The patient’s story and outlook were inspiring. He was effusive and warm. The lecturer’s cold clinical appraisal was a sharp contrast to this demeanor. I left the lecture feeling uneasy. The patient had offered himself up to us, standing emotionally naked before the class. He was there to supplement the technical details of the lecture with the human side of the disease. It did not feel right to me that he should also have been physically stripped down.

||Read Develop Compassion before Medical School||

There is no question that our lecturer, Mr. G’s oncologist, had saved this man’s life. It seems that the two of them are on good terms – Mr. G had, after all, agreed to speak to our class. And if he was fazed by being briefly exposed, he made no indication of it. Even still, I was bothered. Here was a man who was proud to have gotten his disease under control and built the strength to stand up straight despite the vertebrae that had imploded under their own weight. And here was his doctor, lifting up his shirt to point out that his back was not, in fact, straight.

To generalize about physicians, and particularly physician-scientists, it is a group continually pursuing truth. Physicians do not trust therapies until they have been extensively studied and proven effective in large clinical trials and written about in peer-reviewed medical journals. All statements of fact are subject to scrutiny and analysis. Pursuit of truth drives scientific discovery and pushes medicine forward. Was it this need to uphold truth that drove our professor to point out the inaccuracy in the patient’s story with objective physical evidence? Was it for our benefit – to see that the skeletal damage of multiple myeloma does not simply go away with surgery?

||Read Falling in Love with Medical School||

Our professor is an excellent teacher – he broke down the incredible complexities of hematologic oncology in lectures and reinforced our understanding with clinical scenario labs and patient stories. He is a respected researcher and clinician. In so many ways, he is aspirational, but in a single moment in a single lecture he failed to exemplify the humanism and respect for his patient that I consider central to medicine. I believe that his urge to teach overrode his duty to show his patient compassion.

It is difficult to recognize when it is appropriate to teach and when it is better to simply listen. If, as future physicians we are constantly seeking truth, we run the risk of getting so distracted by inaccuracy that we fail to truly hear and respond to our patients. We all regularly face this tradeoff between truth and compassion: A friend embellishes a story in a retelling in front of other friends; a colleague takes credit for some of your work in a meeting; a patient overstates his progress in an auditorium full of students. Do you say something – rectify the untruth? Or do you suppress the urge out of compassion for your friend, your colleague, your patient? As a future physician I draw on the line on the side of compassion far before exposing the truth ever means exposing my patient.

||Read Self Disclosure in Medicine||

The post Truth and Compassion in Medicine appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>