Preclinical Archives | ProspectiveDoctor The premier resource for future doctors. Tue, 21 Feb 2023 02:50:36 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.1 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/cropped-pdr-favicon-rounded-1-32x32.png Preclinical Archives | ProspectiveDoctor 32 32 Active Learning for Deeper Learning https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/active-learning-for-deeper-learning/ Sat, 01 Dec 2018 17:17:55 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=6370

Getting into medical school is a fantastic achievement. Personally, I am the first person to go to medical school in my family. As I opened my acceptance, I was thinking now there is nothing stopping me from becoming a cardiologist! Then after the first month of medical school, I started hearing rumors about these big …

The post Active Learning for Deeper Learning appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

Getting into medical school is a fantastic achievement. Personally, I am the first person to go to medical school in my family. As I opened my acceptance, I was thinking now there is nothing stopping me from becoming a cardiologist! Then after the first month of medical school, I started hearing rumors about these big “step exams” that would be a major factor in determining what type of doctor I could become. Then came the stress as I read SDN forums about the tests and heard horror stories from upper-level classmates. After successfully completing these tests you realize being a good test taker is not indicative of how good of a doctor you will become. Any student that has put in the hard work to be accepted into medical school likely has the intelligence, drive, and compassion to be an excellent clinician. However, succeeding in undergraduate studies does not necessarily mean you have learned good studying and test-taking habits. For example, active learning is a great studying technique that will help you succeed and perform well in medical school.

Read More: Important Tips for Step 1

Well, I am here to tell you that they are just tests and tests can be conquered as long as you have a strategy that works for you. I worked occasionally through my third and fourth years in medical school as a USMLE tutor for my fellow students. This was not an official job but my teachers asked that I guide certain struggling students. The biggest mistake I saw fellow classmates make when I was helping them prepare for the USMLE is not having a game plan and using passive study methods.

One student had crushed her MCAT and had been doing very well in her coursework but failed her first practice test for step one. Her mistake was only reading without utilizing active study methods and not doing enough practice. She was rereading all of her first and second-year books over the preceding months. She was putting more time into studying than many of her peers. If anybody reading this is a musician or an athlete imagine attempting to perform at a concert or a game without first having weeks, months, or even years of practice beforehand. Test-taking is like any other skill it requires first the knowledge base and the skill to utilize that knowledge base effectively.

Read More: MCAT Retake – is it worth it?

To learn the material well you need to employ active learning. Read the material while taking notes on key concepts. Then find ways that work for you to review and remember the key points. Employ flash cards or group study techniques to review these facts. During group studying volunteer to teach a confusing concept.  Nothing reinforces difficult material like being responsible for teaching that material to others. Real long-term learning requires repetition and active participation.

Developing proper test-taking skills requires completing as many questions as possible in a test-like environment.  Don’t casually complete UWorld on tutor mode and expect to improve your test-taking skills. You need to simulate the exam by doing randomized and time question blocks.  And then while reviewing you need to employ the same active learning methods utilized during book studying. This way you will be entirely at ease on test day. It will feel like another day of practice!

If you got into medical school you have what it takes to perform well on your step exams. All you need is for someone to give you the tools to succeed. Active learning and practice are the keys to your success. Don’t let a test score hold you back from your dream specialty!

By: Nathan Wheeler MD, PGY1 University of Wisconsin Internal Medicine

Crafting your ERAS application correctly is crucial to landing the residency of your dreams. Luckily, MedSchoolCoach has physician advisors who’ve served as program directors. They’re ready to give you their insight on navigating the residency application process. Click the link below to book a free consultation with a member of our team!

Book a Free Consult Now

The post Active Learning for Deeper Learning appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
5 Things I Wish I Knew First Year of Medical School https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/5-things-i-wish-i-knew-first-year-of-medical-school/ Mon, 23 Feb 2015 18:10:30 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3334

As a first year medical student, I was wide-eyed and somewhat clueless. I did not know what to really expect, but I felt as ready as I would ever be. Looking back, there are definitely some things I would tell/warn past-self. Everyone’s first year medical school experience is obviously different, but here are 5 things …

The post 5 Things I Wish I Knew First Year of Medical School appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

As a first year medical student, I was wide-eyed and somewhat clueless. I did not know what to really expect, but I felt as ready as I would ever be. Looking back, there are definitely some things I would tell/warn past-self.

Everyone’s first year medical school experience is obviously different, but here are 5 things I wish I knew first year of medical school:

1. Annotate lecture notes into First Aid
Every second year told all the first years not to worry about USMLE Step 1 during first year. I think this was good advice. There is no reason to worry about Step 1 that early. But I don’t think annotating first aid with lecture material necessarily counts as worrying about Step 1. First Aid is not only a helpful study tool for first year lectures but annotating it helps with future Step 1 studying during second year since all your notes are in one place.

2. Utilize Firecracker
I discovered Firecracker as a second year and instantly wished that I used it during first year. Firecracker is the perfect tool for me because I prefer flashcards and repeated testing as opposed to rereading and making outlines. Firecracker covers a lot of physiology as well, which would have nicely supplemented first year physiology lectures.

||Read: How I Study in Medical School||

3. Develop a strong relationship with an MS2
My school has a big sib little sib program that pairs MS2s with MS1s, but my big sib never reached out to me and I was too lazy to reach out to him. I met some other MS2s throughout the year but never really made an effort to build strong relationships with any of them. Looking back, I wish I did reach out to these MS2s because having an MS2 guide/mentor me would have made my life a lot easier.

4. Don’t compare yourself to your classmates
I already knew I did not want to compare myself to my classmates as I started medical school. But it’s incredibly difficult not to compare, especially since is it part of human nature. When I compared myself to my classmates, I would always wonder whether or not the admissions committee had made a mistake by accepting me. Although that feeling did not last long, I’m still fighting the temptation to compare myself because the comparisons just create unnecessary stress and anxiety.

||Read: A Future Doctor’s Greatest Struggle||

5. Keep doing what makes you happy
This is another principle that I tried to keep when starting medical school while failing to realize just how important it was. I love hanging out with friends, playing/watching sports, reading, and exercising. I tried not to sacrifice those things completely but found myself slowly doing so for the sake of studying. I’m still struggling with my “work-life balance” but I can confidently say that now I set aside time for the things I love to do and give me peace.

The post 5 Things I Wish I Knew First Year of Medical School appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Why Get an MBA During Medical School? https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/get-mba-medical-school/ Sat, 21 Feb 2015 02:43:47 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3327

By Shane Burke I am more than half way through a combined MD/MBA program.  Because I frequently get emails from prospective students asking me about our program, I thought I would share some general advice for students considering a combined MD/MBA program in a more public form.  Here are the three most important points to …

The post Why Get an MBA During Medical School? appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

By Shane Burke

I am more than half way through a combined MD/MBA program.  Because I frequently get emails from prospective students asking me about our program, I thought I would share some general advice for students considering a combined MD/MBA program in a more public form.  Here are the three most important points to consider before applying to combined MD/MBA degree program.

First, I always tell people to only go for a combined degree if they have a good reason for doing so. My own reason to pursue the MD/MBA degree was related to personal experience. Without going into too much detail, my mom suffered from health problems when I was growing up and she struggled to afford adequate heath care because, at that point, heath insurance companies could deny patients with pre-existing conditions. My mother was effectively priced out of the insurance market and was forced to pay her doctor bills with credit cards. Fortunately for our family, however, things changed when my dad got a new job with excellent health benefits. I am happy to report that my mom is now much improved, however, nearly 15 years later, my parents are just now getting out of the debt form that legacy.

Thus the reason I personally decided to pursue the MD/MBA degree was because I wanted to be the sort of doctor who could truly advocate for patients, like my own mother, who needed affordable health care.  I wanted a greater understanding of the overall health care system, so that I could help patients navigate through it. While it might not require an MD degree to learn this, I have found that few of my peers outside of the degree program have the same depth of understanding about these types of issues as I have.

The next thing to consider is what medical specialty you want to go into. When entering medical school, you don’t need to have your mind made up about what specialty you are going to pursue (and if you do, that will probably change). But for those rare few who know exactly what they want to do, especially those want to pursue a competitive specialty, it may be best to avoid the combined degree program. After all, it is a second degree with its own additional work that will require the investing of time away from your medical studies.

So for you future dermatologists / radiologists / ophthalmologists / urologists / plastic surgeons / orthopedic surgeons / neurosurgeons, definitely take this decision seriously.  Make sure that you would really be happy having an MBA instead of entering your preferred specialty, as you may not be able to have both. Despite the positives enumerated above, this blunt advice is something that I wish I had when I started this journey.

Lastly, don’t do it for the money! This may sound counter-intuitive because an MBA is all about managing money, right?  True, but the MD comes first in the title “MD, MBA.”  The MD supersedes everything. I believe that if you go through the trouble of going to medical school, a significant amount of your career should be spent being a doctor and seeing patients. If you have aspirations of starting a company and running it to an IPO, it’s un-realistic to think that you could have a thriving practice. If you’re this person, I’d encourage you to ask yourself if you really need an MD to do achieve your goals. It may be best for you to go straight to traditional business school. You’d be stealing a spot in medical school from someone that really wants it and you would also be wasting a lot of time and money on a skillset that won’t benefit you in the future.

I hope this post had some helpful insights into pursuing an MBA during medical school. Are you in a combined degree program and thought I left something important out? Maybe you’re an applicant still on the fence about taking the leap? Whatever, the case, I’d love to hear your thoughts – shoot me an email! As a bonus, to help you figure out how competitive you’re chosen specialty is, check out the following links.

https://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/PD-Survey-Report-2014.pdf

https://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Charting-Outcomes-2014-Final.pdf

If you’re viewing this in the future, be sure to look for a more updated version with a quick Google search. Enjoy!

 

 

 

The post Why Get an MBA During Medical School? appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Breaking Bad News https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/breaking-bad-news/ Tue, 10 Feb 2015 23:43:30 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3296

During a medical school interview, particularly in a multiple-mini-interview (MMI) format, you might be asked how you would go about breaking bad news to a patient. While this task might seem unfair to ask of a candidate medical student, it is no less daunting for me – now a second-year student, and in fact, for …

The post Breaking Bad News appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

During a medical school interview, particularly in a multiple-mini-interview (MMI) format, you might be asked how you would go about breaking bad news to a patient. While this task might seem unfair to ask of a candidate medical student, it is no less daunting for me – now a second-year student, and in fact, for practicing physicians.

This week, NPR reported about the challenges doctors encounter when discussing a cancer prognosis with a patient. Many, though not all, patients will want to know how long they have to live when faced with the often terminal cancer diagnosis. “How long do I have?”

Being able to answer this question gets to the very essence of the role of a doctor. As a scientist, a physician might tell her patient the median survival time, using data from the medical literature. Knowing that he is a critical source of comfort and support, the doctor might instead err on the side of optimism when discussing prognosis with his patient. There are problems with both of these approaches for patients, doctors, and their relationship.

Last year, my friend C was diagnosed with lung cancer. After discussing the prognosis with his oncologist, C was obsessed with “two months.” Whether the doctor told him that the median survival for his late-stage disease was “two months,” worst-case scenario was a “couple months,” or flat out said, “You have two months to live,” I will never know. What I do know is that, from that encounter forward, C was convinced that he had a definite expiration date, and no amount of explaining would allow him to let go of this idea that in T-minus two months he would be dead.

In fact, C lived about seven months, before finally succumbing to his disease at home last January. I was left with the uncomfortable notion that somewhere along the way communication between doctor and patient had failed my friend.

Though we all live with the uncertainty about when we are going to die, most of us feel like death is rather far off, and that we have some degree of control over our fate. By eating right, exercising, and getting enough sleep we can keep our bodies going like well-oiled machines. When, however, the body begins to malfunction on its own without external insult, we lose our sense control and are suddenly operating with an even greater deal of uncertainty. It unmasks the possibility that more might go wrong. It is no wonder then that cancer patients want to know when things will start to go wrong and how long they have left to live. More pragmatically, faced with a limited amount of time, patients must figure out what decisions they have to make and which of their goals they will be able to accomplish.

The problem with generating an estimate for a patient is that it rather artificially imposes certainty on an inherently uncertain and unstable process. Even after being told that “median” survival time means that half of people with the same cancer will live a shorter period and half a longer period, patients like my friend tend to understand the number as absolute, according to psychiatrist Tomer Levin, who works with cancer patients at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York. Therefore, doctors – with the good intent to inform patients that there is a range – are interpreted as giving a sentence.

Perhaps this is why most physicians (63%, according to a study published in the British Medical Journal) overestimate survival of terminally ill cancer patients. Knowing that patients will cling to any specter of certainty, doctors overshoot. In some cases perhaps it seems most humane to offer patients and their families hope. Among many physicians and non-physicians it is agreed that people with something to live for live longer: married men, for example, live longer than the unmarried, and “natural cause” deaths spike on Christmas, December 26, and New Years Day as if people were holding out to make it through the holidays. Perhaps physicians believe that high expectations can be self-fulfilling, and offering hope might actually extend life. However, by being overly optimistic you risk setting patients up for disappointment or the feeling of being cheated when they start to decline “early.”

Dr. Levin suggests giving patients the worst-case scenario, the best-case scenario, and the most likely scenario. This approach allows patients to hope for the best case, plan for the worst, and accept the uncertainty that they will likely fall somewhere in the middle.

I like this suggestion, and hope very much to employ it as I go forward in my career, however I know that my own first inclination is towards optimism. When confronted with the task of telling a standardized patient, (an actor posing in a hospital bed), with inoperable pancreatic cancer her prognosis in our Doctoring class, I was reluctant to use numbers at all, euphemistically telling her that she likely had “on the order of months” to live. I was quick to add that we did not know how long it would be, and it was possible that she might surprise us and live a lot longer. Though it was easier to plan for end-of-life “palliative” care after acknowledging the terminal prognosis, I was overcome with emotion realizing that she was the same age as my mother, (a reaction termed countertransference in psychiatry). This is to say that the duty of discussing prognosis is further complicated by the physician’s own emotional experience.

To make a gross generalization, doctors thrive on knowledge. Operating under uncertainty and admitting that there is a limit to your knowledge is uncomfortable. Additionally, most of us chose the profession to help people – we like being in a position of providing strength and comfort to patients and their families at vulnerable moments. Just as we must be aware that we are providing important information and hope to patients when we discuss prognoses, we must also be aware that quoting numbers from medical literature helps us feel like we can impose order in the face of uncertainty and being overly optimistic helps us cope with our own vulnerability to losing a patient. Our compassion is not reserved entirely for our patients, but is also operating in the interest of self-preservation.

There may not be a right way to break bad news, but rather it is a balancing act of tailoring science and compassion to the individuals on either end of the conversation. Therefore, when in medical school interviews and your future career you are confronted with breaking bad news, know that it is an art as emblematic of your role as a physician as providing life-saving treatment, and a skill upon which all physicians must strive to improve.

The post Breaking Bad News appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Reflections on the First Year of Medical School https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/reflections-on-the-first-year-of-medical-school/ Thu, 13 Nov 2014 07:09:45 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=3083

It’s almost been a full (calendar) year since medical school began. I’m officially a second-year medical student — and this year’s been a momentous one. As I look back on it, here’s some of my reflections on the first year of medical school. Fire hose: Med school really is like a firehose you’re supposed to drink …

The post Reflections on the First Year of Medical School appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

It’s almost been a full (calendar) year since medical school began. I’m officially a second-year medical student — and this year’s been a momentous one. As I look back on it, here’s some of my reflections on the first year of medical school.

Fire hose: Med school really is like a firehose you’re supposed to drink from. It’s high pressure, it’s intense, it’s humanly impossible to get it all down your throat. The idea is that you gulp, swallowing big but manageable amounts and manage to just keep drinking. That’s the challenge.

Intelligence may not help you. If you’re one of those people who managed to get through physical chemistry class napping, or didn’t have to freak out about biochemistry, or immunology in college, you’re probably going to have a tough time in med school. ‘Cause no matter how smart you are, there’s no way of intuitively getting a lot of the material that you’re supposed to learn. A lot of it’s just good old-fashioned memorization. And you might as well resign yourself to having to learn to actually work — because the material may be made easier by your intelligence, but you’ll have to learn to work really hard in a disciplined manner — which for me has been terribly challenging.

Big fish, big pond: Everyone in medical school will be a copy of you. Some will be better copies of you. One of my classmates, went for a 10 mile (I think) run, before taking his MCAT. A group of them get up every morning to practise crossfit before coming to class. Others still, run half marathons, or teach part-time, or design prostheses, or are involved in every single thing at the school. Prepare to deal with a lot of people who may do things you do — and to your mind — better than you can do them. That’s the idea of moving from where you were the best (or the only one) to being a group that has an MCAT average of 512 and a GPA of 3.8.

Find your bliss: Med school’s not nice to you (scratch that – life’s not going to be nice to you). It’s important to find what you love to do, your anchor to sanity and stress release and make it a part of your routine. For me, that’s exercise. If I don’t go to work out for a couple of days, I start feeling a little down. For other classmates (who are musically gifted, unlike my tone-deaf self), it’s music. For others, it’s running, or cooking, or playing with their dogs or significant others. It doesn’t matter what it is — just find what you need and do it regularly.

Open up: Med school seems to foster this intense belief that you need to hide your feelings as weakness that your classmates will use against you. Firstly, if that’s true, you go to a terrible med school. Secondly, nine times out of ten, what you’re feeling is common to a majority of your classmates. Try to share and see — you may be surprised.

Social life: They say you can’t have a social life in medical school. They say a lot of things. They’re wrong. It’s important to have one — it’s essential to your state of mind, and it’s easy to do. Just don’t make your social life the center of your existence, and you’re good. For example, I go out for meals with friends fairly regularly. I go visit people when I can, and I go do fun things when I can.

Time is short: I started med school a somewhat different person than I am today. Who didn’t. I specifically mean in terms of a willingness to do stupid things. Let me explain. I started, not averse to, but not searching for adventure. Now, I’m setting up skydiving plans for the end of the summer. I’m hosting a Thanksgiving dinner at my house (it’s adventurous because I’ve never made a roasted turkey), I’m trying to make international trips when I can, to see the world when I can.

Live with someone: I’m someone who needs a degree of human contact from time to time. That’s called being a human being. Some people are capable of managing without any for a week at a time. Hats off to them — I can’t do that. So, I suggest living with someone. You can choose someone in med school or not. Pros are that they’re not going to throw a party the night before the anatomy final, unless they’re really fun. They’re going to get your stress, and you can help each other out. Cons are, they’re in med school. You need friends from outside of med school. I live with a classmate, and it’s great, but in that situation, find people not in medicine you can connect with.

Be better: Every day of your life, you should be better than the day before. It sounds exhausting. But it’s important. So, this summer, I’m learning to cook a few more dishes than I have in the past, as well as continuing to try to get into shape. Find what you’re weak at, or want to be better at, and go.

Don’t get doughy: I say this with the conviction of being a recovering Pillsbury Dough Boy. I started college, and over the course of college, put on 60 pounds. The first year of med school I lost 20 of those. A lot of my classmates gained instead. Med school’s stressful, and we all like to stress eat. So, try to exercise, stock up on healthy food, don’t eat at every pizza thing the school does.

Prepare to be poor: I’m going to graduate medical school $250,000 or more in debt. Accept that, and chant it to yourself. It’s not meant to scare you, and you’re meant to push it to the back of your mind. It makes failing out of med school an expensive proposition but they actively work to prevent that. Still, that leads me to…

…but don’t live like a pauper: Since you’re going to be $250,000 in debt, at least live a little bit. Don’t subsist on Ramen noodles and water, and don’t live in a cardboard box. But, at the same time, no need to mistake yourself for a Rockefeller. Moderation in all things, as Petronius said. Still, sometimes a nice dinner at a nice restaurant, with a good bottle of wine can make a week. Just saying.

Sarab Sodhi is a fourth year medical student and masters in urban bioethics candidate at Temple University School of Medicine.

Reposted with permission from in-Training.

In-training

in-Training is the online magazine for medical students. It is the agora of the medical student community, the intellectual center for news, commentary, and the free expression of the medical student voice. All articles on in-Training are contributed by medical students around the world and are edited by its staff of volunteer medical students. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Tumblr, or email us to get involved.

The post Reflections on the First Year of Medical School appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>
Truth and Compassion in Medicine https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/truth-compassion-medicine/ Tue, 07 Oct 2014 05:08:42 +0000 https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/?p=2861

You are standing naked in front of an auditorium of people wondering how you got there – you jolt awake, sweating, breathing hard – so relieved. But what if you did not wake up. What if you found yourself in front of 100 medical students, belly exposed, while your oncologist pointed out the damage that …

The post Truth and Compassion in Medicine appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>

You are standing naked in front of an auditorium of people wondering how you got there – you jolt awake, sweating, breathing hard – so relieved. But what if you did not wake up. What if you found yourself in front of 100 medical students, belly exposed, while your oncologist pointed out the damage that cancer had wreaked on your spine?

||Read Emotional Intelligence in Medicine||

Several weeks ago, we learned about a “classical presentation” of multiple myeloma from a patient generous enough to share his story. A formal lecture on this disease, in which cancerous white blood cells accumulate in the bone marrow causing bones to break with little provocation, preceded the patient’s ten-minute talk about his experience with cancer. The lecture covered the details of multiple myeloma’s cellular and subcellular features, the “natural history” (how the disease progresses without treatment), and therapeutic strategies. In other words, we had a strong foundational understanding of the disease by the time the patient stood up to speak.

Mr. G is in his mid-sixties, but looks at least ten years younger. He has salt-and-pepper hair and a well-groomed beard. He wore a green polo and khaki shorts. As he began talking he reached into his pocket for a folded-up note he had written to “keep his story straight.” Looking up from the page, he mentioned that he had come alone because telling his story in the presence of his wife would bring him to tears – he did not want to cry in an auditorium full of students.

||Read Physician Shadowing and the One-Minute Mentor||

Like many people with multiple myeloma, Mr. G suffered broken ribs and multiple compression fractures (meaning that his vertebrae were being crushed by gravity) before his cancer was diagnosed. These fractures affected his posture and strength. When your bones break under the weight of your own body, it is difficult to do activities that build and maintain muscle. For a man who had led an incredibly active life, running a double-digit number of marathons, this disease prevented him from even washing dishes during a period after back surgery when he was confined to a wheelchair.

Just after Mr. G had described the corrective surgery to realign his lower back, his oncologist – our lecturer – lifted his polo without warning. Since Mr. G was facing us, his white belly was squarely exposed. The oncologist reoriented his patient into a profile view and pointed out the lingering kyphosis, or curvature of the back. “Stand up straight,” the doctor instructed. “You have a little bit of a kyphosis here (upper back) and a little bit of one here (middle back)… compared to most it’s pretty good.” Our lecturer let go of the polo and the shirt’s hem fell awkwardly down as the patient straightened it and continued his story.

||Read Personal Statements and Emotional Topics||

His telling was upbeat and forward-looking. At the insistence of his doctor, he mentioned his 32 rounds of chemotherapy, but preferred to tell us about the physical therapy, which has taught him to stand up straight and “do things that old people can’t do.” He even demonstrated several exercises for us. “Where your mind goes, your body follows,” he offered. He concluded by telling us that that in 2011 he thought he would “meet his maker” and today he is the best salesman at his company and that things could not be better.

The patient’s story and outlook were inspiring. He was effusive and warm. The lecturer’s cold clinical appraisal was a sharp contrast to this demeanor. I left the lecture feeling uneasy. The patient had offered himself up to us, standing emotionally naked before the class. He was there to supplement the technical details of the lecture with the human side of the disease. It did not feel right to me that he should also have been physically stripped down.

||Read Develop Compassion before Medical School||

There is no question that our lecturer, Mr. G’s oncologist, had saved this man’s life. It seems that the two of them are on good terms – Mr. G had, after all, agreed to speak to our class. And if he was fazed by being briefly exposed, he made no indication of it. Even still, I was bothered. Here was a man who was proud to have gotten his disease under control and built the strength to stand up straight despite the vertebrae that had imploded under their own weight. And here was his doctor, lifting up his shirt to point out that his back was not, in fact, straight.

To generalize about physicians, and particularly physician-scientists, it is a group continually pursuing truth. Physicians do not trust therapies until they have been extensively studied and proven effective in large clinical trials and written about in peer-reviewed medical journals. All statements of fact are subject to scrutiny and analysis. Pursuit of truth drives scientific discovery and pushes medicine forward. Was it this need to uphold truth that drove our professor to point out the inaccuracy in the patient’s story with objective physical evidence? Was it for our benefit – to see that the skeletal damage of multiple myeloma does not simply go away with surgery?

||Read Falling in Love with Medical School||

Our professor is an excellent teacher – he broke down the incredible complexities of hematologic oncology in lectures and reinforced our understanding with clinical scenario labs and patient stories. He is a respected researcher and clinician. In so many ways, he is aspirational, but in a single moment in a single lecture he failed to exemplify the humanism and respect for his patient that I consider central to medicine. I believe that his urge to teach overrode his duty to show his patient compassion.

It is difficult to recognize when it is appropriate to teach and when it is better to simply listen. If, as future physicians we are constantly seeking truth, we run the risk of getting so distracted by inaccuracy that we fail to truly hear and respond to our patients. We all regularly face this tradeoff between truth and compassion: A friend embellishes a story in a retelling in front of other friends; a colleague takes credit for some of your work in a meeting; a patient overstates his progress in an auditorium full of students. Do you say something – rectify the untruth? Or do you suppress the urge out of compassion for your friend, your colleague, your patient? As a future physician I draw on the line on the side of compassion far before exposing the truth ever means exposing my patient.

||Read Self Disclosure in Medicine||

The post Truth and Compassion in Medicine appeared first on ProspectiveDoctor.

]]>